3 ms·
I'm torn between admiring the tenacity of people trying to manufacture anything in a totally broken environment and wondering why they don't just leave.
by wmf 8y ago
I'm torn between admiring the tenacity of people trying to manufacture anything in a totally broken environment and wondering why they don't just leave.
- samspenc 8y agoThe problem is that in order to emigrate from where they are (third-world / developing) to another country (likely first-world / developed), they would need to move on one of these visas: (a) student (b) worker (c) family member of someone already in said country. (a) requires a substantial financial outlay, (b) requires a job offer AND visa sponsorship from a hiring company and (c) is probably easiest but requires a family member to be already present in the country with a solid visa status.
- microcolonel 8y agoProvided your country is not inherently inhospitable to life, which in this case it isn't, I think it is reasonable for people to have a degree of national pride (in addition to numeric reality of emigration: only so many can go).
- ganeshkrishnan 8y agoBecause that's all you have ever known. Watching TV or documentaries of cushy life seems sci-fyi or something that you dont't think about too much just like watching star wars doesn't make you colonize other planets.
- vkou 8y agoBecause the First World is doing its best to keep people out of it. Someone wants to come to <Developed Country>, to do useful and productive work? We can't have that! We're all out of work that needs doing! I mean, sure, our bridges are occasionally falling over, my street is filled with potholes, daycares are limited, and cost parents thousands of dollars, classrooms are overcrowded, for some reason 30 minutes of a nurse's time gets billed at $5000, and the line at the DMV is 40 minutes long, but I assure you - there are no jobs here!
- jesssse 8y agoWhy would the first world want third world immigrants?
- vkou 8y agoBecause the first world has no shortage of useful, >100% ROI work that needs doing, and immigrants are willing to do it. The fact that this is viewed as a bad thing is testament to how utterly insane our economic system is.
- jesssse 8y agoWhat jobs are you talking about? Why would first world workers want to compete with third world workers?
- nine_k 8y agoYou also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled. They cost money; if the immigrants pay less in taxes than they receive in social benefits, they are a net economic loss. And, as you may expect, a poor immigrant likely pays little or even no taxes if their income is low enough. Also, lowering the price of labor in a particular industry makes other people in it be paid less, or fired. As a result, they buy less, etc, slowing down the entire economy, influencing maybe your own wages.
- cabalamat 8y ago> You also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled Quite a lot of countries don't.
- vkou 8y ago> You also have to provide the immigrants with whatever social spending to which locals are entitled Do you? Why? I'm not saying you shouldn't, but I am saying this is an assumption worth questioning. Also, consider that adult immigrants save your social services one of the biggest costs borne by our society - a K-12 education. Someone with a high school diploma arriving to the US is a flat-out gift of ~$140,000 worth of education.
- Havoc 8y ago>wondering why they don't just leave. It's not that easy. The vast majority will never have a viable shot at leaving. Basically you either need a lot of money or a professional degree (doctor, lawyer, programmer etc).