4 ms·
Having spent a fair bit of time looking into applications for gesture inputs (kinect and leap motion mostly) I can tell you the hardest part by far will the use
by tootie 8y ago
Having spent a fair bit of time looking into applications for gesture inputs (kinect and leap motion mostly) I can tell you the hardest part by far will the user experience design. Gestures are extremely unintuitive on their own. Users need really clear prompts and/or training to understand how to use them. And if you want to innovate and create new and subtle gestures as your product evolves, it only gets worse.
The leap motion is already pretty good and has some useful applications, but it's still very, very niche. The Soli looks like a real evolution of the technology in terms of both precision and how embeddable it is, but it's going to have the same challenges in user adoption. I'd expect this kind of thing to get more traction in industry than in people's homes.
- microcolonel 8y agoI figure the only reliable way to extract gesture intents is to define them abstractly (as a set of drawings or what have you), have a large number of people try to execute them, and then design/learn the detector based on that.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoI've worked in this space for educational software. You hit the nail on the head. Detecting what people do with their hands is easy. Building a UX out of that is hard.
- sizzle 8y agoMicrosoft Hololens does a great job with gesture input onboarding and discoverability/usability in context of virtual keyboard use.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoConcur. Even screen based gestures, rather simple ones, when they are not standard or common, tend to be difficult to acquire. Every time I switch phones, I'm lost in the semantics, and don't care to learn the new ones so much. It's almost a matter of standards than anything - if everyone could really agree what '3 fingers this or that' meant ... we'd already all be doing it.