The only way this kind of experiment can have meaning is if 1) somebody can hit a very high percentage correct a high percentage of the time or 2) over all, the

The only way this kind of experiment can have meaning is if 1) somebody can hit a very high percentage correct a high percentage of the time or 2) over all, there is a trend that is unexpected. I would be very surprised if said grad student actually believed you were psychic. A result in the significant region is NOT significant. A set of results in the significant region is.