2 ms·
I accept that Wardell's description of events may have been misleading, though by "good faith" I meant Brad's initial attempts to work with Fred and Paul, inclu
by mcv 8y ago
I accept that Wardell's description of events may have been misleading, though by "good faith" I meant Brad's initial attempts to work with Fred and Paul, including trying to hire them, offering to sell them the rights, and generally keeping them up to date. That's not something he had to do, but he did it nonetheless. None of that means anything legally of course, and Fred and Paul don't owe Brad anything for that. They made clear they still had their own plans for the franchise, though maybe not on what timescale they might work on it. Their announcement seems to have been a surprise to Stardock and it seems to me that's what set bad blood between them and Brad, and made Stardock feel forced to defend their own sizable investment.
I've read up a bit more on the topic by now, and especially an Ars Technica article linked to in another comment seems to give a good impression of where things have gone wrong. Stardock seems to either honestly believe or fraudulently claim to have bought more from Atari than Paul and Fred claim Atari still owned at that point.
I do think Brad Wardell is an honest fan, but he's also the CEO of a company that may have paid too much for too little, and invested too much into their game without owning all the rights they would have liked to. He did try to unite all the rights to the game in one place, whether it was his own hands or those of Fred and Paul, but was rebuffed in both cases. And while that may have been disappointing for him, Fred and Paul don't owe him anything in that regard.
I was also not aware yet that Stardock eventually did include SC2 characters in their game after having originally promised not to, but I believe that only seriously happened in a DLC that I assume was only created after relations broke down and Stardock decided to go all in on this.
At the end of the day, though, it seems Stardock assumed or pretended they owned more than they actually did, bet too much on it, hoping for Fred and Paul's endorsement which they never got. And now they've got a garbage fire that they need to turn into a success.