14 ms·
Cafe opens in Tokyo staffed by robots controlled by paralyzed people
- alias_neo 8y agoThis is fantastic. Although I'm currently unable to watch the videos, I'm hoping that the people controlling the robots have various forms of feedback so that the interactions can give them some much needed human contact. If they do open a permanent cafe of this type I'll be sure to visit next time I'm in the area.
- chrischen 8y agoThey appear to have a video monitor with a camera feed from the robot, but I can’t figure out how they actually control the robot and how responsive it is.
- pmx 8y agoThe example i saw had a woman who had control of her eyes but nothing else. She had a computer monitor with eye tracking software installed. She could look at controls on the screen in order to command the robot. This was all overlayed on a live video feed from the robot. I'm assuming she also had sound since people were telling the robot verbally what their order was.
- dpflan 8y agoThis is fascinating! If you're interested in some of research on neurotechnologies (e.g. BCI-controlled robots/robotic limbs), check out the BrainGate research group: https://www.braingate.org/ https://www.braingate.org/
- b_tterc_p 8y agoThis is a great concept. It does feel weird though that it’s tied to an anime... I can’t tell why exactly this exists. Is it a venture into much needed independence for paralyzed people? Or... is it horribly distasteful advertising that will soon be taken away?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- antepodius 8y agoCould easily be both. Turning a profit by making use of people who were previously less useful? It's a capitalist's dream.
- hiccuphippo 8y agoAnd in exchange make them useful and able to gain a wage themselves.
- antepodius 8y agoYep. I'd probably spring at this opportunity if I was paralyzed and couldn't do anything else.
- opencl 8y agoI highly doubt that advertising a 10 year old anime would be very profitable. If anything it's an ad for the robots. The robots designed specifically to help disabled people. Two of the three cofounders of the company were bedridden for long periods of time due to illness and wanted to help people in similar situations. They also employ several physically disabled people as remote workers. It won't soon be taken away though, it already shut down. It was intended as a short pilot run. They plan to partner with some existing restaurants for the same sort of thing on a more permanent basis starting next year.
- canada_dry 8y agoI imagine this could work with other jobs where disabled humans could augment a robot/drone e.g. security guard, house sitting. But - of course - the human interaction component is probably the most fulfilling for the operator.
- thinkingemote 8y agoLet's replace self driving cars with remotely controlled chauffeurs.
- sigfubar 8y agoStraight out of the John Scalzi novel! Our science fiction writers need to adjust to the quickening pace at which their ideas are turned into reality.
- sempron64 8y agoFor those wondering which novel: John Scalzi's Lock In. I enjoyed it, though I generally find his work hit-and-miss. It' s a detective story set in the near future where a significant percentage of the population is paralyzed due to a pandemic. The paralyzed operate in society by using android avatars. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lock_In https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lock_In
- GrifMD 8y agoI enjoyed the book and the premise is interesting, but there was just something missing that made it truly good. (I know this is the worst book report ever)
- tsimionescu 8y agoOn the one hand, giving disabled people some activity that helps them be independent and care for themselves sounds great! On the other hand, the idea that this could become a weapon against disabled people (why are you staying on benefits? go out and get a job for yourself, you lazy paraplegic!) is... scary. Especially given that it sounds mostly like a marketing gimmick, and that the very thing allowing them to interact with the world is not their own, but property of the store owners - i.e. they can't take the robot and move to a different caffe, they are tied to the benevolence of their boss. Overall, this is much more distopic than utopic, and should be discouraged in this form; but the technology is interesting and could be an asset in the lives of many people.
- MordodeMaru 8y agoI guess special regulation is required. After all, there isn't a huge market for paralyzed people out there, thus the cost of opportunity of changing jobs is small anyway. I see your point though but disagree with the dystopian tag: if there is any chance to free mentally healthy but physically paralyzed people it is through robotics and technology.
- whatshisface 8y ago>On the other hand, the idea that this could become a weapon against disabled people (why are you staying on benefits? go out and get a job for yourself, you lazy paraplegic!) is... scary. This one restaurant can't employ more than a tiny fraction of paraplegics, so I doubt that will happen. Sure, irrational people could use that argument, but irrational people can already use a lot of irrational arguments. If remote operation of drones by paraplegics suddenly becomes a major part of society, so that operations like this restaurant would be a significant part of the policy debate, paraplegics would be better off and potentially not need benefits. Wouldn't that be an ideal goal?
- claudiawerner 8y agoIt depends on the nature of the work as to whether it is an ideal goal or not. If it is dehumanizing work, or perhaps even the fate of a paraplegic child to have their only career option being a "robot waiter" in a cafe, maybe there's a problem with that. Being "better off" is not only measured in terms of having wealth or a stable place to live (indeed with the same argument one could argue that slavery is justified because the slaves are "better off" living under a master rather than dying on the streets), it is also measured in life choice freedom and happiness. What of paraplegics as restaurant managers, for instance? A related point from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy page on Affirmative Action[0]: >Many factories and businesses prior to 1964, especially in the South, had in place overtly discriminatory policies and rules. For example, a company’s policy might have openly relegated African-Americans to the maintenance department and channeled whites into operations, sales, and management departments, where the pay and opportunities for advancement were far better. If, after passage of the Civil Rights Act, the company willingly abandoned its openly segregative policy, it could still carry forward the effects of its past segregation through other already-existing facially neutral rules. For example, a company policy that required workers to give up their seniority in one department if they transferred to another would have locked in place older African-American maintenance workers as effectively as the company’s own prior segregative rule that made them ineligible to transfer at all. Consequently, courts began striking down facially neutral rules that carried through the effects of an employer’s past discrimination, regardless of the original intent or provenance of the rules. [0] https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/affirmative-action/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/affirmative-action/
- tossaccount123 8y agowow, using technology to increase productivity to make up for stable population rather than importing millions of people who will be out of jobs due to technological advances in a few years. Truly a game changing strategy
- claudiawerner 8y agoIt's strange how these discussions are framed in terms of the dehumanizing "importing people". Maybe it's a reflection in the minds of those who say it of the idea that people are only means to an end, commodities to be imported and exported.
- hopler 8y agoThat doesn't make sense. If productivity increase is inevitable, it's not a game changer strategy. If technology increases human productivity, then immigrants won't be unemployed in a few years, consumers will be wealthier.
- somebodythere 8y agoConsumers will be wealthier only if the productivity gains from automation end up in consumers' wallets--and because employment is the main way that money gets into consumers' wallets, this is not a given.
- airstrike 8y agoWhere exactly do you intend to fit all of those immigrants in one of the world's most densely populated countries? And the jury is still out on if, when and how many people will be unemployed due to technical advances.
- aeontech 8y agoJapan’s local governments are trying to give away millions of abandoned houses: https://www.travelandleisure.com/travel-news/japan-free-abandoned-house https://www.travelandleisure.com/travel-news/japan-free-aban... Similarly to rural Italy, France, Spain and USA, as people move to urban centers, rural population falls and small towns die. Japan’s demographic situation makes their case extra difficult at the moment.
- bregma 8y agoRobots are autonomous mechanisms. These are waldoes. Not to belittle the purpose and sentiment (and kudos to the effort to better enabling those with physical restrictions), but an androideqsue waldo is just not a robot.
- jimmydddd 8y agohttps://laughing-stalk.blogspot.com/2016/12/an-open-letter-to-well-actually-guy.html https://laughing-stalk.blogspot.com/2016/12/an-open-letter-t...
- claudiawerner 8y ago>No, you're right, Well Actually Guy. It's not just used by emotional abusers. It's also used by socially tone deaf people who seek to belittle the experiences of others in order to score debate points, or force their way into a discussion that has absolutely nothing to do with them. This seems much too assuming; sometimes technicalities are important to a good discussion, and of course this ties into the concept of sealioning[0] too, but revealing sealioning is a better tool to use against such people. Sealioning is where people don't recognise that you don't want to debate everything, so they continue to pester you. But once committed to a discussion, the tools of skepticism, doubt and rigor are all very useful. They may be useful (within some margin some of us might find agreeable or disagreeable) on a site almost expressly for interesting perspectives - Hacker News. Often I'm happy that there's a "well actually" guy to provide nuance where it might be needed. Maybe it's not needed, but often it is. There is a time and place, and many of the author's examples are examples of the wrong time and place to "well actually". It doesn't mean the points are wrong. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sealioning
- jimmydddd 8y agoGood points.
- drugme 8y agoIt's a news article, after all -- and fundamentally more about, you know, people rather than technology. So in that sense the distinction hardly matters.
- matt_morgan 8y agoI always thought this is how we should clean our houses (when we pay other people to clean our houses). Robovacs are great for smoothish floors, but most other cleaning tasks are too complicated for autonomous robots. With a good humanoid robot controlled by someone living anywhere, it would be easier.
- kwhitefoot 8y agoWhy not employ a human being directly?
- mikepurvis 8y agoThen that human being has to actually travel to your house and do the entire job start to finish. The idea of a robot vac (or similar) that can do 80% of the job itself but ask for help from a trusted operator over the internet is really interesting.
- hopler 8y agoSo this solves the problem of rich people who don't want to live near poor people but do want their labor.
- gammateam 8y agoFinally? And most “rich people” want to live in desirable neighborhoods and poor people cant afford to do so, the residents also want their houses clean It is currently incredibly unproductive to get your house cleaned It is simply going to be much more efficient to let Pakistanis on Fiverr control your automaton
- mikepurvis 8y agoYuck, that is a good point. At the same time, is the need to house residential cleaning staff really what drives the creation/maintenance of integrated neighbourhoods? For my part, I live in a pretty blended downtown neighbourhood (Kitchener, Ontario), and balancing the need for affordable housing with the constant pressure to "clean up" certain areas and turn brownfields into glitzy new condo towers seems to be something that's largely managed at the city council level.
- mavdi 8y agoChrist, that second video is Black Mirror AF.
- cjdell 8y agoAs well intentioned as this may be, I get the feeling this might be the first step to a world like the one depicted in the movie "Surrogates".
- AlanSE 8y agoThe concept of that movie was really insightful, but the trailer looked kind of terrible. Was there any Ghost In The Shell kind of deep philosophy, or was it just a Hollywood excuse to blow things up and do completely unrealistic action scenes?
- Symmetry 8y agoShip Who Sang here we come.
- tkubacki 8y agoFor me even better idea would be to create coffe&chat type of Cafe. When real people can talk with other real people, though via robotic interface (contrary to human controlled robotic waiters which can be replaced with AI controlled robotic waiters at some point).
- jbhatab 8y agoMost positive and inspired startup concept I've seen in a while. Serious props to the founders for pushing boundaries with this.
- loosetypes 8y agoThis case sounds like a positive But it’s a bit scary that the telecommute, which maybe hasn’t, I think, caught on - at least as a means to include in-demand, distributed “information” workers - might catch on at scale when purposed in a way that could physically exclude workers with “menial” jobs from the need to live locally.
- abledon 8y agoStarcraft dragoon anyone ?
- aaron695 8y agoSo it's obviously fake. But no one on HN can find a link to how/what the fake bit is? Did it even open for instance? No one here has a grasp on robots/disabilities/cafes that they can see through it? The footage of the "Real people" was posted the day of the opening - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AJ7jxgs_M8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2AJ7jxgs_M8 did it stay "open"? Living in a fantasyland of ideas that DON'T help people with disabilities makes you worse than someone who doesn't care, at least they don't take money and waste it. More footage, very much a staged production still, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nuxdjOxhh3w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nuxdjOxhh3w So the walking/moving seems autonomous - https://twitter.com/KyokoJGD/status/1067357154800062464 https://twitter.com/KyokoJGD/status/1067357154800062464 So you get to talk with someone at home with a disability. And the gimmick is there are pretend robots (A tall Roomba basically). The reality is actually ok. And replicatiable, people I think would go to a cafe to talk to someone with a disability given a few different gimmicks. One of the operators YT and twitter was interesting to read - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=co85Ki0pzcA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=co85Ki0pzcA https://twitter.com/koki_sixx https://twitter.com/koki_sixx
- blhack 8y agoThere is a charity that my family supports that works with developmentally disabled people. One of the interesting things I learned when I attended one of their fundraisers was that part of their mission was finding jobs that developmentally disabled people would excel at due to their disability. For instance: the guy who takes the ticket at the theaters in my city (Phoenix) is often a DD person. I thought this was odd, until I made the connection that this is literally a partnership between that company an the charity I'm talking about. Most punk kids will get bored at this job, be snarky, not want to do it, etc. But some people with certtain DDs actually really enjoy it. They get to talk to people, they feel useful instead of feeling like a burden, they get a paycheck, etc. And for the company (harkins theaters) they get a happy, competent employee that enjoys their job. It's a win win. And it's a perfect example of embracing the concept of "differently abled" instead of disabled. Made me really happy to learn that.
- confiscate 8y agogreat observation. I noticed the same phenomenon but did not know there is a back story
- Rodeoclash 8y agoInteresting. Your post reminded me of this story in Australia recently. While this man wasn't placed through a charity, he found a similar enjoyment in his job https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3869008/McDonald-s-worker-syndrome-Russell-O-Grady-celebrates-30-years-job.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3869008/McDonald-s-...
- Balgair 8y agoI once interviewed with a company in NC that only employed blind people (to manufacture reading glasses, of all things!). NC has a provision for sub-minimum wage payments for those with disabilities [0]. This is to encourage employers to hire those with disabilities and give them at least some form of a wage. Per the interviewing process, it really seemed to help a lot of disabled people have a life. Their jobs got them out of the house/care facility, interacting with other people, and gave them a purpose in life(however mundane). Though I declined the job, it was an incredible company and view into the day to day lives of disabled citizens and their struggles. More states should consider such provisions to see if they may work for their people. [0] https://www.employmentlawhandbook.com/wage-and-hour-laws/state-wage-and-hour-laws/north-carolina/minimum-wage/#5 https://www.employmentlawhandbook.com/wage-and-hour-laws/sta...
- ianai 8y agoI wish more shift work was done this way. There have got to be so many people working grueling hours and harming themselves otherwise needlessly.
- cfqycwz 8y agoI don't think this is just semantics—isn't this actually a cafe staffed by paralyzed people, who control robots? This headline is bit like saying a warehouse is staffed by forklifts, controlled by operators.
- jplayer01 8y agoThis is about people being able to do the job from home. So no, this isn't the same thing.
- kazinator 8y agoThey seem to have cooling fannies in their fannies. :)
- known 8y agoShell Oil exclusively employs disabled people in India
- srikanthkalin 8y agoits one of the great thing keeping going guys