6 ms·
> But at the world level, it's just some of us choosing to consume more than we produce right now, and others of us choosing to consume less than we produce rig
by dnautics 8y ago
> But at the world level, it's just some of us choosing to consume more than we produce right now, and others of us choosing to consume less than we produce right now.
I don't think it is that simple. 1) If the world is overleveraged you wind up in a situation where the insolvency of one debtor dominoes over to the lender, who is then unable to pay the next debtor, etc. In one sense some leverage means we are interconnected, which is good because we are likely to pay attention to each other, but if it gets too much, that the effects of bad events can spread.
2) By the nature of compounding interest, having a system that depends on leverage (as ours does now) puts a societal requirement on growth that is enforced through fiscally punitive reinforcement... So that is a fundamental reason why there is a lot of consumption, environmental destruction, and energy demand, even when we try to be active towards conservation -- our current economic structure (and i'm not talking about 'capitalism') simply is not compatible with those goals writ large.
3) when a individual cannot pay their debt, it is because they consensually took on that debt. When a sovereign nation cannot pay its debt, often times the effects are generational, and very much nonconsenual. The current generation cannot go back in time and vote against the profligate spending of the previous generation. One wonders if this is ethically tenable, yet every government does it. Moreover, when a government overspends, the ill effects of that overspending typically hurt the poorest the hardest.
- pjc50 8y ago> When a sovereign nation cannot pay its debt, often times the effects are generational, and very much nonconsenual. The current generation cannot go back in time and vote against the profligate spending of the previous generation. One wonders if this is ethically tenable, yet every government does it. I do think this might be one of the big questions of the 21st century. Stable society requires long-term commitments (debt, investment), but people demand the ability to swing policy back and forth on 4 or 5 year timescales. > Moreover, when a government overspends, the ill effects of that overspending typically hurt the poorest the hardest. This is usually inflicted on them by the lender of last resort, the IMF.
- votepaunchy 8y ago>> Moreover, when a government overspends, the ill effects of that overspending typically hurt the poorest the hardest. > This is usually inflicted on them by the lender of last resort, the IMF. Is what way? I’ve never heard of the IMF demanding this. The method of “austerity” or reducing a deficit could very well include taxes on the rich. It is a local choice to hurt the poor instead (and then blame the IMF).
- pjc50 8y ago> I’ve never heard of the IMF demanding this Not to be rude, but that can only mean you've not been paying attention. Stiglitz wrote an entire book on the subject, "Globalization and its discontents": https://www.theguardian.com/business/2002/jul/06/globalisation https://www.theguardian.com/business/2002/jul/06/globalisati... The IMF were notorious for providing the same advice to different countries with only the name changed (and in one anecdote of his, forgetting to do the search and replace). They are still at it: https://www.taxjustice.net/2018/07/06/the-damage-of-international-monetary-fund-conditionality-call-for-urgent-rethink/ https://www.taxjustice.net/2018/07/06/the-damage-of-internat... Currently going on in Jordan: https://www.alaraby.co.uk/english/news/2018/6/3/thousands-protest-in-jordan-over-imf-backed-austerity-measures https://www.alaraby.co.uk/english/news/2018/6/3/thousands-pr... > reducing a deficit could very well include taxes on the rich. It is a local choice to hurt the poor instead No, the IMF demands specific changes as part of the loan conditionality.
- dnautics 8y agoIts still a negotiation process; the imf is probably just lazy, procedurally and intellectually... In the end, if they get their money back they don't care that much. For many countries politically wheedling out of their obligations is a real strategy, and the easiest way to do this is to discredit international lending, which, in turn is easiest to do by inflicting the pain of austerity on the poorest instead of the politically connected.
- pjc50 8y ago
- just_one_time_ 8y agoThis guy Bitcoins.