5 ms·
Of course there will be changes. But the subways and light rails will still be required for a certain level of throughput. The New York City subway, for example
by bobthepanda 8y ago
Of course there will be changes. But the subways and light rails will still be required for a certain level of throughput. The New York City subway, for example, carries 60K people per hour per direction on a pair of tracks, while a car lane carries somewhere in the range of 2K per hour per direction. Self driving cars may improve lane utilization, but not by up to 30x. Shoving people into cattle cars hurtling down a track is just more space-efficient than dedicating an engine and seats for at most four people at a time.
Scooters and bikes have an effective range, particularly in places like LA that can have quite long commute distances.
Motive power source doesn't really change much.
Intra-urban flight would increase required energy for transport a lot and also move the crapshoot that is today's roads and traffic above our heads, ready to hurtle down at us.
Boring tunnels being cheaper has yet to be proven, since the main issues with tunneling are that tunnels have to be tailored to ground conditions.
Shuttles to Mars doesn't change how I get to and from work across town, the same way that airplanes did not.
- foota 8y agoShouldn't a bus have similar throughput to a subway though, with no traffic?
- lotsofpulp 8y agoEmbarking and disembarking passengers takes much longer on a bus.
- sempron64 8y agoOn the Select Bus Service (certain express routes) in NYC, passengers buy tickets outside the bus and ticket inspectors spot check them during the ride, similar to trains. Passengers can get on through the back door as well. This significantly improves embarkation time, making it similar to a train.
- jimktrains2 8y agoSubways have multiple cars per train, anywhere from 1 to 10, most places falling into 4-6. A bus has one; even articulated buses usual have a smaller capacity than a single subway car.
- chrisseaton 8y agoNo - subway trains can travel 50 mph or more - a bus can’t do that on city centre roads.
- shhehebehdh 8y agoIn theory, but NYCs rarely go that fast. This is changing though. I saw a news article recently about how they are lifting the speed limits on some sections of track as repaired signals come online.
- michaelper22 8y agoThough this probably counts as rarely, least some of the trunk line I've been on give the illusion of high-ish speeds. Examples: - Queens Blvd express (Forest Hills to Roosevelt Ave, Roosevelt to 36 St) - 7 Ave IRT express (from far downtown to 96th St) - Lexington express (City Hall to 125th, save for going through the switches south of 42nd St)
- rayiner 8y agoThe DC Metro averages 33 mph, including stops. I’d be surprised if NYC’s express lines didn’t hit 50 routinely.
- sempron64 8y agoThey do not, the max speed limits on rare long stretches of track are around 45 mph. Most stretches are well below this. https://ny.curbed.com/2018/12/19/18146933/mta-new-york-subway-speed-limit-test-train https://ny.curbed.com/2018/12/19/18146933/mta-new-york-subwa...
- bobthepanda 8y agoIt is worth noting that NYC and DC have fundamentally different design philosophies that result in different average speeds. New York's system is designed around walking to stations. All the way to the end of the lines, stations tend to be about a half mile apart. There are express lines but even those become locals on at least one end, with half-mile stop spacing. DC's is an auto-oriented system, where you're expected to drive to the stop and then take the train in from the suburbs. As a result, while there is dense stop spacing in the center, distances between stations in the suburbs get progressively longer and longer. It's over these long stretches in the suburbs that DC is able to attain much higher speeds.
- jcranmer 8y agoA single bus can move about 100-200 people. A single subway train can move about 1000-1500 people, an order of magnitude more.
- leetcrew 8y agowouldn't it be more fair to compare a single subway car with a bus? nothing stops you from running a "train" of buses.
- munk-a 8y agoIt isn't really that fair, the critical time sink starts shifting to offload/onload time and there is a lot of waste having to load each bus individually. This is why developed subway systems with high usage end up with large trains, that's the best way to speed up the system, reducing the delay caused by trains waiting for other trains that are stopped in the station.
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoEven a "train" of two buses is impractical for most bus routes because of the weight, poor turning radius and so on. I'm pretty sure going any longer than two is virtually impossible.
- closeparen 8y agoA single bus has 25-40 seats, so those other 160 people are going to be pretty miserable. An articulated bus might be able to move closer to 100 people comfortably.