3 ms·
The thing to remember is that psychology is a field that has a well-worn history of being driven by heavy misinterpretation of flawed experiments, and psychomet
by jcranmer 8y ago
The thing to remember is that psychology is a field that has a well-worn history of being driven by heavy misinterpretation of flawed experiments, and psychometrics in particular tends to vary from the awful to the truly execrable in this regard. IQ and the Big-5 personality tests are the best of the field, but we're not talking Standard Model-level of verification--these theories are the nearsighted one-eyed kings of the land of the blind.
The current consensus among psychologists is that intelligence is not driven by one single factor. Rather, there are separate kinds of intelligence (e.g., crystallized and fluid intelligence), and there may be a master throttling general intelligence factor called g. As psychology came around to this viewpoint, IQ tests have been retooled to measure g... except g can't be directly measured. So g is teased out of intelligence tests by statistical means as the primary factor of correlation, and the fact that there does exist a mildly strong correlation is taken as evidence that g exists. (And if you're saying to yourself that correlation is not causation and that this argument is circular, well, there are plenty of psychologists, if a distinct minority, who would agree with you on that point).
Most psychologists, I expect, would prefer to talk about intelligence in terms of the subcategories such as crystallized and fluid intelligence, for which there is stronger evidence and more readily accessible metrics. (Most IQ tests also spit out these scores as well, but it's the IQ part that is the most widely broadcast).
- maroonblazer 8y ago>Most psychologists, I expect, would prefer to talk about intelligence in terms of the subcategories such as crystallized and fluid intelligence, for which there is stronger evidence and more readily accessible metrics. (Most IQ tests also spit out these scores as well, but it's the IQ part that is the most widely broadcast). When talking about IQ, i.e. 'g', this incorporates both crystalized and fluid intelligence. So to say that there's stronger evidence for these vs IQ doesn't seem to make any sense.
- toasterlovin 8y agoExcept that IQ predicts real world performance on cognitive tasks. In fact, it is the single best predictor of job performance that exists.