4 ms·
It seems like the author is setting up a straw man representing the IQ test as some omnipresent (or at least somewhat prevalent) test administered widely. He th
by ineedasername 8y ago
It seems like the author is setting up a straw man representing the IQ test as some omnipresent (or at least somewhat prevalent) test administered widely. He then lambastes it for all its faults (some of his accusations are correct).
But the reality is that IQ tests are only very, very rarely used. In fact a career on the periphery of academia, academic testing, and their efficacy in predicting academic success at the University level, I have never, not once, not from any colleague or at any conference encountered mention of an IQ test as something to be considered for practical use. I have a lesser degree of familiarity with grade school/high school testing methods, but (in the US) I am similarly unaware of any common practice here.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> the author is setting up a straw man As a former options trader, this is Taleb in a nutshell. He builds and attacks straw men for popular consumption. (The one time he tried running a hedge fund, it failed ruinously.)
- fujimotos 8y ago> The one time he tried running a hedge fund, it failed ruinously. Source? Taleb AFAIK does not publish his track record in a verifiable manner, so we're left to wondering if his bragging about himself really matches his record.
- maroonblazer 8y agoAren't most standardized tests - SAT, ACT, GRE, etc - essentially IQ tests? We don't call them that, but they're testing cognitive ability nonetheless.
- ineedasername 8y agoNo, these are some of the tests I work with. Pop culture turned them into a proxy for IQ or Inteligence etc. They're not. The SAT for example is highly targeted towards one specific goal: predicting level of success academically in the first year of college, and only the first year. They make no other primary research claims about the utility of how the test results should be used, and in dealing with them they are very up front about the importance of a good all around picture of a student including HS GPA, rigor of courses taken, etc., along with SAT as one of multiple metrics. I repeat, it is pop culture that has distorted these tests beyond all reasonable correspondence to their actual intent.
- chillacy 8y agoThe old SAT correlated more with standard iq tests and can be used for admission into MENSA from what I remember.
- ineedasername 8y agoThe old SAT has a statistically significant correlation, but if memory serves (it might not, it's been a while) the correlation wasn't great, it has something like an r-squared value of 0.4 to 0.5, so a majority of the variance in outcomes was not explained by differing performance on the tests.
- swebs 8y agoNo, those are designed specifically to test your level of education. An IQ test would be something like Raven's Progressive Matrices.
- jamesdmiller 8y agoIf you care about what college someone graduated from, you care about something highly correlated with IQ. Indeed, part of the reason why elite colleges are able to command such high prices is that, as you mention, we rarely use formal IQ tests when evaluating people and so graduating from an elite college is the best way that high IQ individuals can signal intelligence.
- ineedasername 8y agoIt may be that attending such colleges is highly correlated to IQ; I'm unaware of research on that topic. (as closely as my field is related to that topic, highly elite schools tend to be outliers and aren't in the scope of my own activities) What I can say somewhat definitively is that any such research would be fairly outdated. IQ tests simply are not used at any scale that would be required to study such a correlation, and so if there are recent studies they'd likely rely on sparse data from a small subset of (possibly self-selected & biased) students. SAT or other standardized scores are a different matter. But as my other comments in this thread state, those tests are very much not designed and calibrated to measure anything beyond 1st year college success. 1st year success does itself correlate with 2nd year, grad rates, etc., but the signal degrades significantly as time goes on.
- jamesdmiller 8y ago"IQ tests simply are not used at any scale that would be required to study such a correlation" I think you are wrong about this. There are a huge number of social scientists who study IQ. Also, IQ tests are very frequently given to children, and to everyone who wants to join the U.S. military.
- ineedasername 8y agoEdit: I'm speaking from my knowledge of this topic in the US. I'm not ware of practices in other countries. I'm familiar with the school systems and their on boarding processes for new students in many parts of the country, and am not aware of any pockets that systematically utilize IQ tests. You're correct about military recruits, but I don't know if their scores are reflective of the general population. Certainly the composition by demographics differ somewhat from the general population, which woild cause me some concern if I were trying to generalize from their IQ tests to the broader population. However, the context of my comment was about IQ related to elite colleges, and that remains an area where the data is sparse for IQ scores of such students. There simply isn't much if any research being performed these days tying IQ to success in higher education.