6 ms·
My guess is that the question never comes up. If you're an adult thinking in terms of an abstract blueprint of a weapon, the thought of a child stumbling on the
by andrewflnr 8y ago
My guess is that the question never comes up. If you're an adult thinking in terms of an abstract blueprint of a weapon, the thought of a child stumbling on the dirt-strewn concrete implementation of your device is very far from your mind, almost impossible to think of. The only way you would think of it is if someone pulls the possibility off a checklist built from cases like this. Be honest: if you saw the picture in the article without the surrounding context to make you think about toys, how likely would you have been to think of them that way? To think that someone else would think of them as toys? I'm guessing it's low. My first visual impression was of dead bugs or cigars wrapped in leaves (which I'll grant might be just as tempting to a child).
Not that any of that makes it ok. I'm more convinced than ever that failure of imagination is a form of morally judgable (what's the right word here?) negligence. But it would have been hard to see that far into the future in this case.
- cam_l 8y ago>If you're an adult thinking in terms of an abstract blueprint of a weapon.. You are probably not making mines. I don't know. It makes perfect sense to me the kind of mass murdering sociopath capable of working on such a device would find it perfectly ok to target children. Only one physicist quit the Manhattan project iirc. Maybe the indiscriminate nature of mass murder is not such an irksome burden for a weapons designer or distributor. Maybe the people that find themselves in that line of work fully understand the risks but just don't care.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoI wouldn’t design weapons for the US government today, but if we were facing another Hitler and another WWII-era Germany, along with Japan? Remember that we wouldn’t have the benefit of hindsight and know that Hitler would shoot himself in the foot with the Russian front and wasting resources on his insane genocide. The Manhattan project might be one of the most prominent exceptions to the sweeping generalization you’re making. It’s also unhelpful and unwise to frame people you don’t like or understand as sociopaths, or crazy.
- cam_l 8y agoI think it is both helpful and wise with the benefit of hindsight to understand the banality of mass murder. It was not just the Germans who were doing it. Sociopathy describes very well (outwardly at least, it is a cultural term not a psychological term) the necessities of lack of empathy, and use of cruelty for personal gain, required for such pursuits. I never said crazy. I do not say such a thing lightly, i don't say it merely because i don't like them (although seriously, how could you like someone responsible for the deaths of tens of thousands of children?) nor do i say it because i do not understand them. I say this because i do understand. What i don't know is if they were never faced with the visceral effects of their life's work. Or if they were, and they simply don't care. What i do know is mostly they never publicly denounce it or try to atone for their bastardry.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoIt might be helpful to study the history of the Manhattan project then, as well as its aftermath for those involved. You’d find your monsters (Edward Teller), the man who despite believing in the necessity and inevitability of it all, took his own life (Oppenheimer), as well as those who initiated it, and regretted it only with the value of hindsight (Einstein). You’d learn about the range of justifications, reasons, and personalities involved instead of painting them as monsters. Most of all it can help to contextualize these actions in the history of those who did similar things, and those who refused. If your choices are not “murder children” or “have a lovely glass of dry sherry,” but rather “murder children or “have your children murdered” it can make the choice more difficult, and less likely to attract sociopaths.
- cam_l 8y agoOh, thanks, had momentarily forgotten Oppenheimer(!?) ..that is about as strong an act of atonement one could make. I have actually read a lot about it (though it may not seem that way), along with the justifications and reasons etc. I believe people have a tendency to act in their day to day without ever confronting their own complicit cruelty. Division of labour and all. The difficult choice would have been to face the reality and opt out in that situation, as Rotblat did. The truth of the matter though was more of "murder children" or "someday the possibility of somehow your children getting murdered and also have a glass of dry sherry". I also never said they were monsters, that mischaracterises everything i said about the banality of it. What i said was i find it easy to believe the kind of person capable of working on cluster bombs or toy land mines would not have an issue with killing children. Whatever fucked up justification they used to live with the rest of their work would function just fine to also include future children. Despite all the years between Vietnam and Laos and Afghanistan and now, mines are still being designed made and planted. Yes. They definitely know now. Also, despite the facts that you mentioned, despite the hindsight of doubt in the necessity of the dropping of the bombs, a lot of people still defend it to the hilt. Still need for it to have been justifiable beyond any evidence to the contrary.
- jdietrich 8y agoThe devious ingenuity that went into land mine design is quite remarkable. The consequences for the civilian population were broadly regarded as irrelevant. My "favourite" example is the Valsella VS-50, a viciously clever piece of engineering. It has practically no metal content, making it almost impossible to detect; this also makes the mine cheaper to produce and impervious to corrosion. The amount of explosive is carefully calibrated to blow off your foot without killing you, because wounded soldiers are more expensive for the enemy to deal with than dead soldiers. The pressure plate is isolated from the trigger with a compressible bladder, so the mine will react to the steady pressure of a foot while ignoring the shock from being helicopter-dropped or from explosive or flail demining. That wasn't quite devious enough for Valsella, so they made the VS-50AR. The standard VS-50 will only trigger due to pressure, so once you've done the difficult work of finding them, they're relatively straightforward to render safe. The AR variant has mercury tilt switches, designed to detonate in response to standard mine probing and defusing techniques. If you find a VS-50, you have to act on the assumption that it's an AR, massively complicating demining efforts. The icing on the cake? Valsella illegally exported 9 million mines to the Iraqi government in 1991, via a front company in Singapore. Heroically, some of Valsella's own employees lobbied the Italian government to ban the production of anti-personnel mines, effectively protesting to demand their own redundancy. War is hell. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VS-50_mine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VS-50_mine https://ricerca.repubblica.it/repubblica/archivio/repubblica/1991/02/13/vendevo-ottime-mine.html https://ricerca.repubblica.it/repubblica/archivio/repubblica...