5 ms·
What is the design process like for landmines? Do they consider if they look like toys? Do they put duds in a toy chest and see what a sample of children will p
by Waterluvian 8y ago
What is the design process like for landmines? Do they consider if they look like toys? Do they put duds in a toy chest and see what a sample of children will pick out?
This whole concept really upsets me to think about.
- chris1993 8y agoIt's as if the post-conflict civilian deaths are a useful side-effect. Monstrous
- darkpuma 8y agoYears ago during the Soviet-Afghan War there was a lot of American media asserting that the Soviets had very evilly designed the mines specifically to look like toys with the design intent being to maim children. Few if any ever mentioned that the Soviets had stolen an American mine design (which the American media rarely if ever leveled criticism against.) >"In stark contrast to the lack of public commentary on the Dragontooth system, the subsequent Soviet analogue, the PFM-1, spurred a lot of controversy after being used in Afghanistan during the Soviet intervention in Afghanistan, being a key element leading to the International Campaign to Ban Landmines.[citation needed]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BLU-43_Dragontooth#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BLU-43_Dragontooth#Overview To answer your question more directly, the (official) design intent for the BLU-43 was to create an antipersonnel mine that could be deployed from aircraft without requiring parachutes. To that end, they designed it to be similar to maple seeds (the sort that flutter through the air when falling.) It's doubtful that they considered the possibility that the mines would be perceived as toys, although it should probably be noted that children also like to play with maple seeds...
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoYeah, but the issue is that the Soviet mines were bright green and being deployed in Afghanistan which is notably short on the greenery. By contrast America also had green mines, which they deployed in the jungles of Vietnam. I think the reality is that the Soviets had stocks of green mines and they used them before switching to regionally appropriate camo, but the PR damage had already been done. In addition America tended to use their mines in low population density areas as area denial weapons, while the soviets were a bit more... profligate in their spreading of these mines. About 40 people still die each year in Afghanistan from Soviet mines, and they’ve done fuck all to remedy the situation. In addition, the US involvement in Vietnam is still a national shame, but it tends to be focused on the broader picture of village massacres, Agent Orange, Daisy Cutters and death squads, as well as the sheer stupidity and cruelty of our intervention. Finally, the US invaded during an existing civil war, whereas the Soviets just straight-up invaded to conquer another region. I grant these are fine distinctions when we’re talking about mining civilians, but I think it goes to explain the perception of each country’s activities.
- darkpuma 8y agoThat's fair context, here is some more: In 2017, there were 14 recorded casualties from mines/unexploded remnants of war (ERW) in Vietnam, while in 2016 there were 1,943 in Afghanistan. However since 1975 there have been 105,073 casualties from mines/ERW in Vietnam, while there have been 29,662 casualties from mines/ERW in Afghanistan since 1978. http://www.the-monitor.org/en-gb/reports/2018/afghanistan/casualties.aspx http://www.the-monitor.org/en-gb/reports/2018/afghanistan/ca... http://www.the-monitor.org/en-gb/reports/2018/vietnam/casualties.aspx http://www.the-monitor.org/en-gb/reports/2018/vietnam/casual... The Soviet-Afghan War was started in 1979 when Alfa Group (the KGB's 'spetsnaz') dressed in Afghani uniforms stormed the Queens Palace in Kabul and murdered the Afghani president Hafizullah Amin. Amin had been in office only three months, and came to power by deposing and ordering the murder of his predecessor Nur Muhammad Taraki. Taraki was a communist and before his demise, had plead with the Soviets for military intervention. Before Taraki's demise he and Amin had worked together and together both are known for murdering thousands of civilians and political opponents. The Vietnam War was sold to the American public in 1964 after two separate attacks on USN ships in the Gulf of Tonkin. However in 2003 Robert McNarmara (who was the Secretary of Defense when this happened) publicly admitted the second attack had never happened. The American public was told there were two distinct attacks on two separate nights, but that wasn't true: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HODxnUrFX6k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HODxnUrFX6k I suppose my point is that both wars were huge unpopular clusterfucks that were started on false pretexts, that neither Afghanistan nor Vietnam were placid before foreign intervention, and that excessive mining caused staggering civilian casualties in both countries for many years after the war. Despite what all the above may suggest, I don't really like historic analogies or equivalencies. However given that the BLU-43 and PFM-1 are nearly identical mines, a comparison seems warranted. The mines in Afghanistan are an ongoing issue while in Vietnam it seems to have petered out, probably because it was that many years earlier. In this context the focus on Afghanistan instead of Vietnam is justifiable.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 8y ago>Finally, the US invaded during an existing civil war, whereas the Soviets just straight-up invaded to conquer another region. This is not true. The Soviets were defending already existing communist regime.
- andrewflnr 8y agoMy guess is that the question never comes up. If you're an adult thinking in terms of an abstract blueprint of a weapon, the thought of a child stumbling on the dirt-strewn concrete implementation of your device is very far from your mind, almost impossible to think of. The only way you would think of it is if someone pulls the possibility off a checklist built from cases like this. Be honest: if you saw the picture in the article without the surrounding context to make you think about toys, how likely would you have been to think of them that way? To think that someone else would think of them as toys? I'm guessing it's low. My first visual impression was of dead bugs or cigars wrapped in leaves (which I'll grant might be just as tempting to a child). Not that any of that makes it ok. I'm more convinced than ever that failure of imagination is a form of morally judgable (what's the right word here?) negligence. But it would have been hard to see that far into the future in this case.
- cam_l 8y ago>If you're an adult thinking in terms of an abstract blueprint of a weapon.. You are probably not making mines. I don't know. It makes perfect sense to me the kind of mass murdering sociopath capable of working on such a device would find it perfectly ok to target children. Only one physicist quit the Manhattan project iirc. Maybe the indiscriminate nature of mass murder is not such an irksome burden for a weapons designer or distributor. Maybe the people that find themselves in that line of work fully understand the risks but just don't care.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoI wouldn’t design weapons for the US government today, but if we were facing another Hitler and another WWII-era Germany, along with Japan? Remember that we wouldn’t have the benefit of hindsight and know that Hitler would shoot himself in the foot with the Russian front and wasting resources on his insane genocide. The Manhattan project might be one of the most prominent exceptions to the sweeping generalization you’re making. It’s also unhelpful and unwise to frame people you don’t like or understand as sociopaths, or crazy.
- 8y ago
- toy_boi 8y agoThe “toy” like appearance is pretty obviously an emergent side-effect. Much less for wanting of an “I would NEVER!” attitude regarding the hypothesis of aiming these weapons at little kids; but more to the point, you cen see the intent of the design is generic and unassuming, and not actually coaxing of an audience. It’s designed for air drop, so it has aerodynamic wings. It’s a mine, so it needs to blend into the appearance of the terrain (all mines employ booby trap tactics on some level, since they cannot rely on people to use them to commit suicide). It’s designed to harm military personnel, which are often model examples of some of your strongest humans; which, of course, means it will harm anything weaker than a physically fit 100KG person wearing boots, gloves, flak jacket and a helmet. Mines, as a strategy, fall under the “area denial” category. That means blocking paths. Any path. Area denial means: NO HUMANS. Actually, it means kill anything that moves, including animals. A cargo bay full of these things will stop a column of pregnant women, the elderly, people in wheel chairs. The scope of fittest below fully armed soldier has a lot of bycatch. Sometimes, mines are not even dolphin-safe.