3 ms·
There absolutely is a genetic aspect to intelligence. We need only look at genetic issues like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-linked_intellectual_disability ht
by eesmith 8y ago
There absolutely is a genetic aspect to intelligence. We need only look at genetic issues like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-linked_intellectual_disability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-linked_intellectual_disabili... to see that there is a connection.
The question, I think, is, since concepts like "race" are primarily social constructs (indeed, genetics helped overturn the older view that "race" was an entirely biologically concept), why should we think there is a genetic correlation between race and intelligence?
When you write "It seems that the scientific community", bear in mind that many people in the scientific community are also racist, sexist, and otherwise biased. That is, you can't always infer significance just because there is open dialogue.
You write: "the genetic evidence is POSITIVE". Except the link you pointed to includes "Other scientists gave the paper a mixed reception, ranging from outright dismissal to acknowledgement that the hypothesis might be true and merits further research" and "Assuming that today there is a statistical difference in intelligence between Ashkenazi Jews and other ethnic groups, there still remains the question of how much of the difference is caused by genetic factors." and "Criticism of the genetic explanations" and "Cultural explanations".
At best, isn't it just an hypothesis, based on a single research paper? I do not think that's a substantial base for your argument.
You write "we should be able to have the conversation with people like James Watson". Except, "we" have. How can you have a conversation with someone who isn't listening? What do you do with someone who, for decades, has made unjustified statements like (quoting https://www.sfgate.com/science/article/Nobel-Winner-s-Theories-Raise-Uproar-in-Berkeley-3236584.php https://www.sfgate.com/science/article/Nobel-Winner-s-Theori... ):
> there was a biochemical link between exposure to sunlight and sexual urges. "That's why you have Latin lovers," Watson said. "You've never heard of an English lover. Only an English patient."
> Watson showed a slide of sad-faced model Kate Moss to support his contention that thin people are unhappy and therefore more ambitious.
> "Whenever you interview fat people, you feel bad, because you know you're not going to hire them," Watson said.
> Watson showed slides of women in bikinis and contrasted them to veiled Muslim women, to suggest that controlling exposure to sun may suppress sexual desire and vice versa.
> Watson reportedly went on to suggest that people who live in northern climates drink more alcohol to compensate for the unhappiness they suffer because of sunlight deprivation.
That was 18 years ago. The evidence doesn't support him. Yet he keeps making the same statements.
You write "We should also not write articles like this with condescending dismissal of the very idea as backwards and racist."
What if the idea really is backwards and racist? You've said that you don't have the knowledge of the field to determine what the science is, so I don't think you can make conclude that such comments aren't justified.
"unlikely to get a definitive answer either way"
In many of the things Watson says, we know that Watson's statements are unsupported by evidence. How much more definitive do you want to get?