5 ms·
As I mentioned in the Twitter thread, my chief criticism of cryptocurrency since the beginning is it's naivete of the history and politics of money. The discus
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
As I mentioned in the Twitter thread, my chief criticism of cryptocurrency since the beginning is it's naivete of the history and politics of money.
The discussions about economics applied here focus too much on microeconomic rather than macroeconomic arguments. So they end up missing the point entirely which is this:
Money isn't a neutral instrument and it's not something that can be decoupled from societal/political concepts and structures.
You can evaluate it as though it is neutral, but it has not ever been and will never be a neutral instrument because of the historical tendency for resources to pool and therefore become power centers, among other things.
Therefore if you view cryptocurrency as having the primary intention to de-couple commerce from coercive power structures [1], then you'll see immediately the historical problem. Namely, history doesn't favor distributed power, especially not when it can easily be co-opted by the powerful systems in which they rely.
In the best case scenario for crypto-utopians, millions of people transact and do commerce on a decentralized currency. In that case, whatever sovereign is most impacted, will then either outlaw commerce by crypto by force or require parity with the sovereign currency and control of the crypto currency through tax payments. This has happened multiple times over the centuries with alt-currencies and they are killed off by the most powerful (see: Most powerful economy/military) organization.
Politically, there is nothing different about Bitcoin than there was with the confederate states dollar for example.
[1] From the original whitepaper: "What is needed is an electronic payment system based on cryptographic proof instead of trust, allowing any two willing parties to transact directly with each other without the need for a trusted third party." https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- jondubois 8y ago>> whatever sovereign is most impacted, will then either outlaw commerce by crypto by force or require parity with the sovereign currency and control of the crypto currency through tax payments That's not possible. Even if all the governments of the developed world coordinated to ban cryptocurrencies or impose taxes on them, this will be an opportunity for developing countries to use cryptocurrencies as a competitive advantage to catch up financially.
- throwawaymath 8y agoUh, how?
- sk5t 8y agoI suppose you could hitch your wagon to the Marshall Islands economy and see how that goes.
- skywhopper 8y agoVery curious about how you foresee "developing countries to use cryptocurrencies as a competitive advantage to catch up financially" working if the cryptocurrencies are unusable in larger economies.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoWhy the downvotes? "traditional" cryptocurrencies are more useful in absence of a stable and reliable banking system and political system. As smartphones spread across developing countries, hypothetical non-minable cryptocurrencies that works well on intermittent or local networking might become relevant.
- mathnmusic 8y ago> history doesn't favor distributed power In that case, why do we have ~200 nations instead of a single world government? Clearly, sovereignty matters to groups of people. "Sovereignty of money does not matter to LARGE groups of people" - might be a more defensible argument.
- manigandham 8y agoWe already have 3 superpowers today with potentially 2 more developing. The others don't matter at scale. It's more likely that the cities will become the dominant form of a citizen's home sovereignty rather than a nation, with only a few national boundaries around the world. People are inherently tribal and human behavior isn't changing anytime soon but countries are quickly becoming stretched too thin to keep up with all the varied and changing populations and their needs.
- woodandsteel 8y ago>In that case, why do we have ~200 nations instead of a single world government? The correct starting question is "why do we have 200 nations, instead of millions of individuals and families living autonomously?" and the answer is: human beings are basically tribal people, and military conquest. And then the answer to your question about why 200 is that military conquest never got any farther before the atom bomb eliminated direct warfare between major nations.
- mathnmusic 8y agoWhy don't we have a single registrar for all TLDs? Why don't we have GitHub as the single repository for ALL software in the world? My point is that sovereignty, innovation etc. are valuables which centralization can't deliver. "Monopolies will maximize profits and therefore, under-supply the product" is Economics 101. So, yes, economics of scale and network effects do encourage centralization but there are counter-balancing forces. What we need is protocols that allow a sliding scale as opposed to non-interoperable silos. DNS, TCP/IP, Git delivered exactly that. While GitHub has the scale and network effects, plenty of people are happily using GitLab, BitBucket etc.
- rdiddly 8y agoA subtlety bears mentioning: History favors both centralized and distributed power, at different times, in different places, in quasi-cyclical fashion. Examples of history thwarting centralization include the collapses of: the Roman Empire, the USA in the 1860s, the 3rd Reich, Yugoslavia, the whole Warsaw Pact, and the USSR. Some of these were later "re-centralized" and some weren't. When things get too decentralized, centralization kicks in. When things get too centralized, decentralization kicks in. It's a balance.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI read the fourth turning some years ago and it repeats effectively the same argument. Previously the histories from Polybius. From my study of it, it's closer to a ratchet. So while dissolution might happen at the highest organizational level, the hierarchies trend toward growing over successive cycles.
- majewsky 8y agoAlso, the number of sovereign nations is just one measure of centralization of power. Economic structures are now more centralized than ever (with, in many cases, a handful multinational megacorps controlling most of each sector).
- hadsed 8y agoA great book about all this if you want to dig in more is "Debt: the first 5000 years".
- panarky 8y ago> Politically, there is nothing different about Bitcoin than there was with the confederate states dollar for example. The big political difference is that Bitcoin transcends borders and national governments. While the United States could have outlawed the Confederate dollar, the United States cannot outlaw Bitcoin because it can be sustained by miners globally. Interestingly, the United States didn't have to outlaw the Confederate dollar, or the Texas dollar, because both of them were destroyed by their creators through over-printing.