3 ms·
Wow. They keep using that word 'experiment' to mean 'I can run whatever code I want on an end user's computer' which is not right. It's an ad. You're pushing a
by jchw 8y ago
Wow.
They keep using that word 'experiment' to mean 'I can run whatever code I want on an end user's computer' which is not right. It's an ad. You're pushing ads. It's not the worst thing in the world if you just call it what it is, but using the 'experiments' mechanism to push ads is scummy and to me a violation of trust.
I've been running Firefox inside of Firejail, a sandbox, lately, primarily as a light form of exploit mitigation, and I think maybe you should too, just in case Mozilla decides to experiment with attacking your computer as well.
I think today I'm going to experiment with QuteBrowser and some other more fringe browsers that are available for Linux.
- clairity 8y agothe difference may not matter to you but it's not an ad because it's not a paid placement. no personal info is shared up front either. obviously you'd share info once you click on it. i don't like ads either, but this seems better than the standard track-you-out-the-wazoo ad.
- jchw 8y agoWhich definition of ad requires it to be a paid placement? As far as I understand it the word advertisement is a pretty broad term. You could advertise for someone for free, perhaps because you have an existing relationship, or perhaps you could advertise for something other than monetary payment. It's an advertisement. Worse, it's an advertisement, for a commercial service, in a place that I didn't want it to be. The last place I wanted something like that to be, really.
- clairity 8y agowe can debate the semantics but i don't think it's a stretch to consider monetary exchange as a feature of advertising (perhaps a more narrow version of your general exchange of value definition). with that said, another commenter noted that this could be paid per action after the fact (CPA), so it could very well be called an ad by any definition. i agree that we shouldn't place ads everywhere, especially in "safe" places. but i'm also concerned with the viability and longevity of firefox.
- darkpuma 8y ago> the difference may not matter to you but it's not an ad because it's not a paid placement. Why should that matter? It makes not a lick of difference to me whether they got paid for it or not.
- darkpuma 8y agoAgreed, it has become clear that this has become Mozilla's version of shouting "it's just a social experiment bro!" after fucking with somebody. It's not cute, it's antisocial.