2 ms·
This story illustrates why New York Times has fixated on aggressive negative coverage of Facebook. Suicide prevention is another area where Facebook is wiping t
by brudgers 8y ago
This story illustrates why New York Times has fixated on aggressive negative coverage of Facebook. Suicide prevention is another area where Facebook is wiping the floor with newspapers. As an information channel, newspapers can't compete in over most of the landscape. The article includes the head of a premier suicide prevention program, John Draper, praising Facebook's initiative.
Data collection may be bad, but suicide prevention is a beneficial byproduct. Data collection may be bad, but the New York Times won't be accused of leading by example. The article is packaged to ping Google, Amazon, and yes Facebook among it's 32 scripts. It's unlikely any of this there to serve a higher common interest than suicide prevention.
The examples in the coverage show how far Facebook outclasses the New York Times.
Facebook said its suicide risk scoring system worked
worldwide in English, Spanish, Portuguese and Arabic
Facebook is working on something relevant to suicide prevention in Mozambique, Algeria, Dominican Republic, and Australia. Beyond it's role in US public policy, the New York Times will always be approximately irrelevant to people in these places.
It's reporting is parochial. Interviewing two experts in New York, four police forces on the east coast and Ohio. To me as a non-absolutist, judgment about the initiative's tradeoffs ought to consider stories from Brazil, Morocco, Mexico, and Canada. Those people don't enter the parochial conversation at the New York Times.
Preventing suicides is the kind of difference journalism is supposed to make in people's lives. The New York Times is driven of "weapons of mass destruction" reporting on Facebook's suicide prevention initiative because it is so completely outclassed as an instrument for journalistic impact on the lives of individuals.