3 ms·
> Irrelevant, that it's not perfect doesn't mean it shouldn't be done. It's not a question of perfection. There are two strains of HIV, one that attacks CCR5,
by jcranmer 8y ago
> Irrelevant, that it's not perfect doesn't mean it shouldn't be done.
It's not a question of perfection. There are two strains of HIV, one that attacks CCR5, and another one where CCR5 is not involved. In Asia, the latter strain is more common than elsewhere in the world; about 25% or so of infections involve that strain. Dr. He appears to have made no attempt to actually ascertain which of the HIV strains were actually involved in the cases at hand.
The evidence is pretty damning that Dr. He was not motivated to conduct a medical experiment; he was motivated to become the first person to achieve CRISPR in humans, and the medical experimentation was merely a means to do it.
- TomMarius 8y agoI was not referring to this particular case at all, I was speaking generally because I think the comment I replied to was also speaking generally. The fact that not all HIV strains might be cured (with this particular gene or any genes) does not mean we should not do it at all.