3 ms·
Like philosophers, scientists chased Truth, but their theories were understood to be provisional—tools for resolving problems as they appeared, models valuable
by keiferski 8y ago
Like philosophers, scientists chased Truth, but their theories were understood to be provisional—tools for resolving problems as they appeared, models valuable only to the extent that they explained and predicted what showed in experiments. A Newtonian model of motion had worked beautifully for a long time, but then people noticed bits of unaccountable data, and relativity emerged as a stronger theory. Couldn’t disciplines like philosophy work that way, too?
It's ironic that the this line is in the article, considering that the notion of "equality = an unquestionably beneficial thing" was quite rigorously attacked nearly 200 years ago by Nietzsche and company. Somehow contemporary philosophers seem to have jumped straight from the late 18th century straight to today, ignoring the entire corpus of criticism that's been written since.
This while simultaneously ignoring the fact that foundational thinkers of Western thought like Plato were extremely critical of democratic values.
- yyrrll 8y agoStill worse, ignoring that philosophy has _always_ proceeded as a statement of theories to be questioned and improved upon. The scholarship is just bad. The whole argument is full of mis-statements of critiqued positions. Anyone interested in the article is better served to start reading Plato, Locke, Hume, Smith . . . .