5 ms·
> Working in Canada where my degree was not certified, all the PEng people would get seriously uptight if I even said "I studied Engineering" or "I have a bache
by naasking 8y ago
> Working in Canada where my degree was not certified, all the PEng people would get seriously uptight if I even said "I studied Engineering" or "I have a bachelor of Engineering".
As a Canadian engineering graduate myself, I don't think that's true. Saying you studied engineering is fine, that's literally what the degree is. Calling yourself an engineer is a different story, and that requires more work. It's like calling yourself a doctor without a doctorate. Notice how I didn't call myself an engineer, and that's because I didn't get my PEng.
- criddell 8y agoDo they let the people operating trains call themselves engineers?
- jpambrun 8y agoNo. https://www.oiq.qc.ca/en/media/pressReleases/Pages/default.aspx?communiqueid=135 https://www.oiq.qc.ca/en/media/pressReleases/Pages/default.a...
- criddell 8y agoThat link isn't very clear. Plus it's only Quebec. I did a little Googling and in Ontario there are exceptions for flight engineer, train engineer, sound engineer, aircraft maintenance engineer, operating engineer, stationary engineer, and hoisting engineer.
- jpambrun 8y agoI am from Quebec, so this what I know. The link says you can't and ask media to stop doing it. It also says that the train engineer union could keep his name because it existed before the law.
- InternetOfStuff 8y agoOut of curiosity: I studied engineering in Germany. There's no such thing as a PEng in Germany -- the only thing is that the title of Dipl.-Ing. (equivalent to MEng), which was the culmination of my studies, is protected. How does it make you feel for me to claim I'm an engineer? (BTW, I get seriously uptight at all the web designers who like to call themselves engineers :-) )
- ThenAsNow 8y ago> (BTW, I get seriously uptight at all the web designers who like to call themselves engineers :-) ) I feel similarly to you, but would extend it to cover most software development, period. With feet in multiple traditional engineering disciplines, I don't see the majority of software development as coming close to the bar of engineering (though some certainly does). And I don't mean that in the sense of licensure, nor am I merely trying to be snooty. But to hear the software world co-opt "engineering" to mean "technical work" is grating.
- foepys 8y agoI am seriously curious, what is the difference between e.g. an mechanical engineer designing a new machine and a person designing a new software system that is intended to be maintained for at least 10 years by various teams? Is there some sort of bonus just because it's physical vs virtual?
- blihp 8y agoI think it's the rigor of the field. The general expectation is that a mechanical, or any other type of engineer, will bring to the table some minimum set of skills and knowledge that other engineers in the same field possess. This is not true in computing since so many people entered the field from so many vectors. Not to mention there's still a hell of a lot of snake oil being peddled because there's so much money in the field of computing. For example: one can't be certain that someone with a Computer Science degree even knows how to program or has any other specific knowledge or skills. Or that someone supposedly with X years of experience with Y understands Y at all vs. just repeating tasks learned by rote. Or that someone who went to a Z bootcamp can actually do anything useful with/in Z. Maybe someday we'll get there, but it's still a long ways off.
- sa-mao 8y agoIf you study engineering. You will probably end up with an engineering degree (something like a doctorate for doctors) which makes completely legit to call yourself an engineer.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> It's like calling yourself a doctor without a doctorate In some countries most medical doctors don't have any kind of doctoral degree. In the UK for example doctors have a bachelor's degree.
- jpambrun 8y agoI have a PhD, but can't represent myself as doctor or use the Dr. Prefix as this is reserved for member of the college of doctors.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThat’s bonkers! Doctor was originally a title for academics before medics borrowed it. I think medics without an MD or PhD shouldn’t be using the title. What country is that in?
- jpambrun 8y agoCanada, specifically Quebec (I am not sure about other provinces). I find it slightly annoying too. However, my degrees are in engineering and it makes sense to me that the engineer term is reserved.