3 ms·
There are several issues: * The technology is still new. We don't have a very strong grasp on the potential ways that CRISPR can go horribly, horribly wrong (a
by jcranmer 8y ago
There are several issues:
* The technology is still new. We don't have a very strong grasp on the potential ways that CRISPR can go horribly, horribly wrong (as in delete-an-entire-chromosome-wrong) and having technology in place to watch for these failures.
* Biology in general suffers from the problem that a lot of our parts are co-opted to do several different things, so knocking out something that is making you sick could have a side effect of suddenly making your kidneys stop working or other serious effects.
* Germ-line edits are heritable. The potential consequences of things going wrong affect more than just the person in question, and the recourse for fixing them is unclear.
* Consent is tricky. The person who is affected is, by definition, not yet alive to offer consent. Given the potential consequences... it's something that is going to want a fairly involved discussion on how to properly seek consent.
The thing about this tale is that the researcher in question flubbed just about everything that could be flubbed. The participants were told by the researcher himself (BIG no-no) that this was an experimental HIV vaccine and apparently nothing at all about it being CRISPR. Furthermore, HIV transmission via paternal sperm donation is very easy to guard against with conventional methods; the gene knocked out may not have actually been sufficient to protect against the HIV strains the father had; and the actual results were pretty damn poor (one embryo was mosaic, another had only one chromosome affected). The general mood after He gave his presentation changed from "oh dear" to "hand me the pitchfork." A silver lining is that it does seem that the Chinese community has been clear in emphasizing that it is not condoning this sort of wildcat experimentation, which is one fear that many people have had in the past.
- TomMarius 8y ago> * Consent is tricky. The person who is affected is, by definition, not yet alive to offer consent. Given the potential consequences... it's something that is going to want a fairly involved discussion on how to properly seek consent. Noone gives consent for their birth > Furthermore, HIV transmission via paternal sperm donation is very easy to guard against with conventional methods; the gene knocked out may not have actually been sufficient to protect against the HIV strains the father had Irrelevant, that it's not perfect doesn't mean it shouldn't be done. Many treatments are not perfect. Of course if it introduces new diseases then it's a problem, but dismissing it because it doesn't solve world hunger is weird.
- jcranmer 8y ago> Irrelevant, that it's not perfect doesn't mean it shouldn't be done. It's not a question of perfection. There are two strains of HIV, one that attacks CCR5, and another one where CCR5 is not involved. In Asia, the latter strain is more common than elsewhere in the world; about 25% or so of infections involve that strain. Dr. He appears to have made no attempt to actually ascertain which of the HIV strains were actually involved in the cases at hand. The evidence is pretty damning that Dr. He was not motivated to conduct a medical experiment; he was motivated to become the first person to achieve CRISPR in humans, and the medical experimentation was merely a means to do it.
- TomMarius 8y agoI was not referring to this particular case at all, I was speaking generally because I think the comment I replied to was also speaking generally. The fact that not all HIV strains might be cured (with this particular gene or any genes) does not mean we should not do it at all.