4 ms·
I once worked in the live entertainment industry. We often had engineers sign off on stage/tower structures. When they got the math wrong things fell on heads
by sandworm101 8y ago
I once worked in the live entertainment industry. We often had engineers sign off on stage/tower structures. When they got the math wrong things fell on heads. Our insurance demanded licensed engineers. Anyone using that term, professing, to be an engineer better be one.
This case essentially removes engineer from the list of recognized professions. That club now only belongs to the doctors and lawyers. Even hairdressers cannot call themselves such without state recognition.
- justinpombrio 8y ago> Our insurance demanded licensed engineers. Anyone using that term, professing, to be an engineer better be one. The guy didn't claim he was licensed. All he said was "I'm an engineer". All the court said was "He can say he's an engineer". This doesn't sound very problematic to me. Like, presumably you'd ask where they were licensed, right? You wouldn't just accept anyone who said they were an engineer, and then rely on the state to issue a $500 fine to anyone who dared use the "E" word without being licensed in the US?
- DaiPlusPlus 8y agoWhat should we call the people who stoke fires on steam locomotives then?
- jdeibele 8y agoTraditionally they're called firemen. Steam locomotives aren't commonly used anymore, so I assume you're making a joke about somebody on a train being a "firefighter".
- lsiebert 8y agoI think the term stoker also applies.
- jdeibele 8y agoCould be, although I think of that as a nautical term. For example when they were talking recently about the coal bunker fire on the Titantic, they said that two stokers per every shift were delegated to shovel the bunker that had the burning coal.
- nkurz 8y agoI think instead he's making a joke about locomotive engineers. Which is actually a good point, but marred by couple issues. First, the "engineer" is the person who drives the train, rather than the person feeding the fire. Second, the term is only frequently used in English speaking North America. Further description here: Why are US train drivers called engineers? https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-magazine-monitor-32758223 https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-magazine-monitor-32758223
- Taniwha 8y agoNo - the judge affirmed that the state can still control who can call themselves a "professional engineer" or "licensed professional engineer" - but allowed anyone to claim to be an "engineer" ... it's a situation akin to being an "accredited teacher" with a teaching credential compared to all of us who teach at one time or another
- naasking 8y agoI guess anyone can call themselves a doctor then, and we'll just have to call proper doctors "professional doctors" or "licensed professional doctors".
- wl 8y agoCall them what they are: physicians. A four year entry level degree in a subject is a bachelor degree, not a doctorate.
- vonmoltke 8y agoWhat's a "proper doctor"? Is someone who obtained a Ph.D. in English Literature not allowed to call themselves "doctor"?
- naasking 8y agoThey have a doctorate don't they?
- chaseha 8y agoCompletely disagree. It says he can call himself an engineer in a non-professional context. Having a ChBE BS, I am an engineer (although no longer working as one). I am not a Professional Engineer (not a licensed PE). There’s a difference - doesn’t mean I should not be able to call myself an engineer, and I’m sure others w engineering degrees would agree
- caseysoftware 8y agoBS EE here. I am also an engineer and approach the world with an engineering mindset. And I would never use "Engineer" as part of my title. For me, once it becomes a title/capitalized, it's no longer an adjective but a designation. My first initial is D and I use that instead of my first name. When people address me as "Dr Casey" I correct them on that too.
- grogenaut 8y agoNon-sarcastic question: Everyone at my company has "Software Development Engineer" on their title if that's their role. That's a capitol E. What's your thoughts on that?
- ghaff 8y agoEngineer is an incredibly widely-used term as part of titles. In addition to SWEs etc., you've got sales engineers, systems engineers, field engineers, etc. When I was in the oil business there were titles like mud engineer (which people joked should have been called mud salesmen). The majority of these people don't have engineering degrees and have never worked in what most would consider an engineering role.