4 ms·
"The below text is a notice from the USPTO about tests they’re removing in order to make it less difficult to pass the test for obviousness. Low obviousness sta
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
"The below text is a notice from the USPTO about tests they’re removing in order to make it less difficult to pass the test for obviousness. Low obviousness standards (silly patents) is not the mains cause of problems, but it aggravates already-problematic domains such as software patents.
...
In 2007, there were seven tests – the classic teaching-suggestion-motivation (TSM), plus six newer tests. Failing any of these tests would lead to rejection due to obviousness. Those tests were put in place in 2007 in response to the landmark case KSR v. Teleflex. Under its new director, David Kappos, the USPTO has now deleted four of those tests."
I don't see how reducing the number of obviousness tests from 7 to 3 makes it harder to pass, when failing any single test causes a patent app to fail the whole thing. Wouldn't having more tests result in a greater % of failures, and hence more patents rejected for obviousness? What am I missing?
- martincmartin 16y agoThey're making it "less difficult," i.e. easier to pass. They claim that's ok because "silly patents [are] not the main cause of problems," so presumably they think they have some leeway.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoAh I see, thanks, misread it.