4 ms·
Saying “this is science” alone as an answer to the validity is really doing science a disfavor. Not only are these consumer grade tests, but there’s been a lot
by azinman2 8y ago
Saying “this is science” alone as an answer to the validity is really doing science a disfavor. Not only are these consumer grade tests, but there’s been a lot of evidence of the fallibility of DNA testing (particularly for crime scene analysis) in recent years, let alone the fact that everything they show is based on models that are constantly updated and effectively best guesses. I really wish they’d be more upfront but it’d probably be too big a challenge to sweeping in new customers.
- paulryanrogers 8y agoIs the science bad or are some labs just sloppy/malicious?
- ethelward 8y agoOn on hand, the science itself is a quickly moving field; on the other one, the more precise tests kits are far more expensive. So these societies have to make compromises.
- doublec 8y agoFor ethnicity results, yes it's based on models and reference samples that are often updated. You should be taking them with a large grain of salt. For the matching with other people it's useful and accurate and is a great way for doing further genealogical research to back up the paper research.
- leaf_house 8y agoRelatedness testing is pretty trivial with modern chip/sequencing tech so this stuff does actually tend to be pretty cut and dry. The big worry is sample swaps but those should hopefully be the exception and not the rule.