Sure. And if you lend me $100 and I refuse to pay it, you're out the money regardless of whether I'm living in a cardboard box or a mansion. But there's a cas

Sure. And if you lend me $100 and I refuse to pay it, you're out the money regardless of whether I'm living in a cardboard box or a mansion. But there's a case to be made that the law should allow you to collect your $100 in the latter case. Obviously it's a lot more complex in the case of a PE firm buying a struggling business. But at a high level, if the company has $X in debts, it is worth $X more to someone who thinks it's possible to weasel out of paying that debt than it is to someone who doesn't. And finding novel ways to make a company more valuable than its current owners think it is is kind of the whole MO of private equity. That's what's going on here - PE firms are finding novel ways to weasel out of paying pension debt, and pocketing the difference. And what people are complaining about is that in this case, the person who's out the money is not able to collect from the courts, despite the entity who ought to be responsible for the debt living in a mansion and not a cardboard box.