6 ms·
> People are going to say mean things to other people. This is never going to change. This case is not about saying mean thigns to other people -- US first amm
by DanBC 8y ago
> People are going to say mean things to other people. This is never going to change.
This case is not about saying mean thigns to other people -- US first ammendment allows people to say mean things to others.
This case is about credible threats of violence being sent via a social network. One of the features of that social network was that you could only see messages from people who were geographically nearby.
--begin quote--
We first address the University’s expressed apprehension about punishing students
for their speech. Put simply, we are satisfied that its First Amendment concerns about
penalizing speech lack a proper basis. The University could have vigorously responded
to the threatening Yaks without implicating the First Amendment because “true threats”
27
are not protected speech. See Virginia v. Black, 538 U.S. 343, 359 (2003) (recognizing
that “true threats” are not constitutionally protected and describing them as “statements
where the speaker means to communicate a serious expression of an intent to commit an
act of unlawful violence to a particular individual or group of individuals”). 7
The Supreme Court and our Court have consistently recognized the principle that
threatening speech is not protected by the Constitution. See, e.g., Watts v. United States,
394 U.S. 705, 707 (1969) (upholding constitutionality of statute making it illegal to
threaten president with physical violence); United States v. Maxton, 940 F.2d 103, 105-06
(4th Cir. 1991) (“Threats to kidnap or injure persons are legislatively proscribable, falling
within that group of expressions, such as fighting words, which are not constitutionally
protected pure speech.” (internal quotation marks omitted)). Moreover, both federal law
and Virginia law criminalize the communication of threats to kill or injure others. See 18
U.S.C. § 875(c) (prohibiting transmission through interstate commerce of threat to injure
another); Va. Code Ann. § 18.2-60(A)(1) (criminalizing electronic communication of
threat to kill or injure another if threat recipient is placed “in reasonable apprehension of
death or bodily injury”).
--end quote--
- mbrumlow 8y agoI don't care what the case is about. We already have laws on threats, its not the Universities job to hide or block those threats. Even if they did somehow block the sites these "credible threats" were posted on it still does not stop the fact that the threats were made. In fact I argue that if the university prevented a threat from reaching me that they could be held liable for any damage done to me should that threat come to fruition -- by blocking my ability to be aware I was in danger. Moreover, even if the Universities did so on their own networks that does not thing for the rest of the internet that lives in each and every students pocket. If somebody makes a credible threat you report it and take action. Banning sites that some people use to make threats is not the solution -- if it were, you might as well ban the entire internet.
- csydas 8y agoAgain, I believe you are misunderstanding the situation and creating an argument based on a misleading headline from the Think Tank that was sourced for the article. The complaint is not that YikYak wasn't blocked -- it's that no action was taken by the University to investigate the threats properly and readily. Blocking YikYak was simply __an option__ which the University could have taken, but that wasn't the thrust of the plaintiffs' argument at all. The point of Blocking YikYak was more of a point that "well, you absolutely could have done something", rather than a prescribed course of action. * I'm sorry, but you're arguing a point that was not made by the plaintiffs and also is not related to the actual court Opinion either. The crux of the complaint is that in light of real, credible threats, the University took no action whatsoever. The Opinion is more about how the defenses of anonymity made it "impossible" for the University to act and that 1st Amendment protections prohibited [the university] from doing so were considered invalid in light of other case law. *Nevermind that YikYak itself had built in a blackout system like this which would rapidly allow Universities to simple blackout the GPS coordinates of the University if there was a request from the Administration. YikYak had a built-in censorship/disabling tool for a long time. No effort would be needed to specifically block YikYak aside from a simple letter on some department letterhead.
- mbrumlow 8y agoI don't think it is the job of the university to investigate or take action. We already have laws -- use those. Universities are not equipped to investigate and have guidelines to do so with due process. Making them responsible completely bypasses entire sections of law. Somebody threatens you at the gym. It's not the gyms responsibility to investigate and take action. You call the cops. That is what you do. Making other organizations reposnable for legal matters is just a way to bypass the law and do whatever the hell you want. Simply put universities can't be the judge jury and executioner of the law.
- alistairSH 8y agoYou do realize that almost every university on the US has its own police force? They are absolutely equipped to investigate crimes, or they’re at least as qualified as the town police would be.
- lokidokiro 8y agoIf there were credible threats of violence, that would be criminal assault: something for the police to investigate. Universities don't have power of subpoena so there is nothing they can do here.