4 ms·
MWU was successful in having the complaint dismissed in US Circuit Court. The ruling in the article is a remand from Fourth Circuit Appeals vacating the US Circ
by brudgers 8y ago
MWU was successful in having the complaint dismissed in US Circuit Court. The ruling in the article is a remand from Fourth Circuit Appeals vacating the US Circuit Court's dismissal of two claims and upholding its dismissal of the third claim. As required, the ruling is based on a favorable reading of the plaintiff's argument (since the case was not heard at trial).
The title of the article is misleading in so far as there is a difference between websites and mobile apps. And perhaps in so far as the specific app involved, Yik-Yak, used geolocation tied directly to specific universities and using MWU's network was a first order means of accessing Yik-Yak in the context of the MWU oriented Yik-Yak community.
Neither party denies that threats of rape and murder were made via Yik-Yak against specific students.
The plaintiffs allege that MWU could have blacklisted Yik-Yak's IP address on it's network. The plaintiffs cited the failure of MWU to block Yik-Yak as evidence of deliberate indifference to Title IX and Equal Protection claims.
The keystone of MWU's defense against the deliberate indifference claims was that blocking Yik-Yak would be a violation of the First Amendment.
4th Appeals determined that threats of rape and murder made via Yik-Yak were threatening speech and ruled on established precedent that threatening speech is not protected. As a matter of legal precedent the court noted the long standing practice of blocking music and video download IP addresses and sanctioning students for copyright infringing downloads as evidence of technical and practical feasibility.
The court vacated the dismissal of the Title IX and Equal Protection Clause claims and remanded back to the Circuit Court.
- dane-pgp 8y agoThose are interesting precedents for the court to choose. Music and video download sites (and apps) that get blocked are presumably ones where the majority of music and video downloaded are done so without the permission of the copyright holders. There is plenty of unlicensed music and video on YouTube, but it is a minority of the content available because of YouTube's filters, so the site is usually not blocked. In the other example, sanctioning a student for copyright infringement only affects the student that has been found guilty. I can't imagine a university disconnecting all students if just one student is found infringing copyright. So, while these precedents do show the technical and practical feasibility of the blocking, they are not examples of long standing practices where the not-protected speech of a minority is sufficient grounds for restricting the protected speech of a majority.
- brudgers 8y agoI can't imagine a university disconnecting all students if just one student is found infringing copyright. Napster.
- dane-pgp 8y agoYes, I mean I can't imagine a university disconnecting all students from all sites and services on the internet, just because one student is using Napster, for example. Blocking all students from using just Napster is much less controversial, given that a majority of files shared on Naptser were copyright infringing.
- brudgers 8y agoI'm unclear on how the idea of blocking the all sites and services on the internet became part of this conversation.
- dane-pgp 8y agoThe initial mention of "sanctioning students for copyright infringing downloads" suggested to me a policy of disallowing specific students from accessing the internet (using university equipment) if they have been caught using it to infringe copyright. This is similar to policies that some ISPs have announced or implemented: https://www.pcmag.com/news/364835/at-t-prepares-to-disconnect-over-a-dozen-pirates https://www.pcmag.com/news/364835/at-t-prepares-to-disconnec... Obviously disconnecting someone from the internet will partially prevent them from being able to exercise their First Amendment rights (not that ISP policies are necessarily covered by the First Amendment directly), but this is an example of a precedent where the person infringing copyright is having just their own rights or options limited. I'm contrasting this example with what is being proposed by the court, which is to restrict the First Amendment rights of all Yik-Yak users at the university (using university equipment), because of the actions of a minority of users.
- brudgers 8y ago
- kayfox 8y agoSo, what would have happened if they UMW had blocked Yik Yak on their network and students continued to use it (since its a smartphone app) on their phones using cellular data?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- csydas 8y agoThe actual Court Opinion misrepresented the actual block option. When YikYak was actually running, a proper block request could be sent to the company to blackout the GPS coordinates of a University from the app, effectively killing the local YikYak community. The app worked based on GPS proximity -- you had to be within 1.5 miles of a given university in order to participate in the "herd" as they called it. This added a lot of character to each individual herd, even if all the groups essentially just reposted the same memes from 4chan/reddit non-stop, but with their own local flavor attached. YikYak had for some time been cooperating with schools and universities to perform the blackouts and even advertised it as a means of compliance and battling harassment through the app. Had a blackout request been made, it would have been effective and the above question would not have been relevant.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]