4 ms·
Adaptation decay has sucked the meaning out of “A Christmas Carol”
- likeItsNothing 8y ago> the corrosive effect of bourgeois white colonialist > culture on everything that is good and sacred Pretty racist thing to say.
- dentemple 8y agoHow I wish this was presented in blog post form instead
- 6cd6beb 8y agoThe user is losing a fight against the format; this post is an absolute chore to read. The author account is such a spot-on display of the SJW stereotype that I'm not sure this post isn't a joke.
- stolenmerch 8y agoWriter skips over a dozen or more adaptations that present the original version with the same brutal depictions of poverty and wealth. They seem a little too thirsty for a contrarian anti-capitalist view and should have spent more time actually doing comparative analysis. Instead, this slog of a twitter thread is a weird takedown of the 1999 version as if the 20 year-old Patrick Stewart movie was all the buzz this Christmas season. This is what Twitter is for, so more power to them I guess. However, I found it to be annoyingly strident in it's presentation of an already very mainstream view -- namely that some Christmas movies are too sentimental and saccharine.
- lovich 8y agoWhy do people continue to use Twitter for long form dialogue like this? A few chained tweets maybe, but this looks to be 10s of tweets with Twitter's UI sticking in between every few sentences. It makes nearly and lengthy discussion unreadable
- TagAsDelusion 8y agothis is absolutely the worst format for any length of text