3 ms·
Since I am not the parent poster, I would like to understand why this completely factual post was downvoted?
by tomcam 8y ago
Since I am not the parent poster, I would like to understand why this completely factual post was downvoted?
- pjc50 8y agoIt's a great example of how to be factually correct while completely missing the point. Saying "well, his summary execution was completely legal" is a bland form of words. The photo shows us what that looks like, and how intuitively horrifying it is. A million deaths is a statistic (or in the case of Vietnam per wikipedia, 1,353,000). An individual death is a tragedy - and here is a photo of that. The casualness and lack of ceremony of the execution is a key part of the impact of the photo. Was means the casual extinction of huge numbers of lives. Modern war means this happens at a distance and is comprehended statistically. "Another few hundred people were fed to the meat grinder today." Photographing it reconnects people to the dead as humans. As for "undermining the war", America's role in Vietnam was always on a really shaky moral footing since it was essentially colonialist; it was always right to question this and "undermine" it.
- tomcam 8y agoThanks for the answer. My question was sincere, and I appreciate your thoroughness.