4 ms·
The argument made in the piece is that there is increased polarization between the haves and the have nots. Successful professionals are haves. I don't know wh
by theoh 8y ago
The argument made in the piece is that there is increased polarization between the haves and the have nots. Successful professionals are haves.
I don't know what nuances the term "upper class" has historically had in California; perhaps it's not the right word for those earning (as little as) a hundred thousand a year. But the idea that there is now a privileged socioeconomic group which no longer blends, at the low end, into the traditionally larger middle class and lower middle class seems like a clearly testable proposition.
In other words, the claim is that the middle class is evaporating and tech professionals are left on the wealthier side of the gap, typically earning "upper class" salaries.
In the UK, a huge proportion of the population identifies as working class, somewhat bogusly. Tech workers tend to be part of what is sometimes called the "technical middle class", a new (post-WW2) and slightly wretched group with little cultural or social capital but strong finances. Ramen-eating programmers are in the technical middle class even if their earnings haven't yet matched those of more established professionals.
I agree that both "working" and "upper" are anachronistic categories.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI think if you're working a job and earning a salary or a little equity, then you're clearly middle class at best. I think it's the working class that's being eroded, leaving the a middle class on one side, and the destitute on the other, with the upper class being the same as it ever was.
- theoh 8y agoWell, the Pew research organization puts everyone who earns above a certain amount in the upper class. It's about 100k. And we know that the rich have got even richer in the last few years, with a thinning of the "middle" earners. There are plenty of articles out there which focus on the erosion of the middle class. As I mentioned, some people (in the UK for example) are invested in the idea of the working class, and draw the class boundaries between working and middle so as to enlarge the working class. Often this is about preserving their own identity rather than assessing the wealth of different social strata. But living in relative comfort has been a middle class thing.