3 ms·
> We have an existence proof with both Android and Windows - and less so with Macs but only because they aren’t as large of a target - with what happens when ap
by izacus 8y ago
> We have an existence proof with both Android and Windows - and less so with Macs but only because they aren’t as large of a target - with what happens when apps are given unfettered access to the hardware and privacy related information even with user permissions.
What exactly happens? A ton of innovative apps can be made? Bunch of enterpreneurs can innovate and built new products without approval from a huge american corporation?
Yes, powerful tools can be abused. But powerful use-cases require powerful tools. What you're defending is akin to saying we should cut out everyone's tongue to defend against people accidentally telling their personal information to strangers. It's NOT a proportional response. You're effectively ceding full control of EVERYTHING you do on your computing device to Google and Apple forever because you're afraid that powerful tool, drivers of innovation and progress, might hurt someone occasionally.
You can't have progress in a kindergarten - instead of demanding that large corporations babysit the public and tell them what to think, we NEED to make sure that people take responsibility for themselves. It's the only way you keep free market and freedom functioning.
- scarface74 8y agoThe existence proof is both Windows and Android and all of the spyware, malware, ransomware, and privacy invasion apps. Yes, powerful tools can be abused....You're effectively ceding full control of EVERYTHING you do on your computing device to Google and Apple forever because you're afraid that powerful tool, drivers of innovation and progress, might hurt someone occasionally. You’re speaking as if this is hypothetical. Thirty plus years of PC use and 10 years of Android is proof that third party developers can’t be trusted and the platform providers have a responsibilty to keep third party providers in check. Given the trade off of inconveniencing a few geeks and not allowing third parties to read text messages, phone logs, etc. I think that’s a fair trade off. I am a developer and have been for 20 years. But the platform providers should be catering to the users. I will install any random app on my iPhone. I don’t worry about whether the app comes from a trusted developer. I know because of the security model that the app can’t do too much damage. we NEED to make sure that people take responsibility for themselves. It's the only way you keep free market and freedom functioning. Again, how has that worked out so far for the vast number of PC and Android users? It has been drilled into computer users heads not to download random apps from untrusted sources on their computers because of the potential for harm. The fact that the iOS App Store does enforce a sandbox actually gave app developers a larger market of people who would try random apps without having to trust the developer. But most importantly, Android has been around for a decade. Where are all of the Android “entrepreneurs” that are getting rich because of their “innovative” apps that are possible because of its lax security model?
- danShumway 8y ago> The existence proof is both Windows and Android and all of the spyware, malware, ransomware, and privacy invasion apps. But... the existence proof is also Windows and Android and the massive market share and staggering amount of innovation that's happened on those platforms. You're forgetting that many of the capabilities that Apple eventually caved on and added to iOS came directly as a result of Android's "we'll let you do that" default motto. There was a period of time where you couldn't have custom keyboards on iOS. There was a period of time where 3rd party apps on iOS couldn't even multitask. Don't get me wrong, Android's permission model needs serious work at this point. But the coin you're holding up has two sides on it. You're writing off a huge amount of innovation that has benefited everyone, Apple users included. Platform power is a continuum -- there's no single right or wrong answer for everyone buying a device, which is why it's good to have multiple platforms with multiple philosophies. Even if you don't care about that though, and you personally enjoy staying closer to the secure side of things, permissive platforms still benefit you as a user because they're testing grounds to find out which capabilities are beneficial enough to end-users to be worth back-porting to the more closed gardens. That's something we've seen repeatedly throughout the years with Android and iOS: both platforms feed on each other in different ways.
- scarface74 8y agoBut... the existence proof is also Windows and Android and the massive market share and staggering amount of innovation that's happened on those platforms. The massive market share is because of cheap phones. The average selling price of an Android phone is a 3rd of an iPhone. And where is this “massive innovation” that is leading to profit either by app makers making apps that can only be made on Android or by device makers? As the old saying goes - “if they are so smart, why aren’t they rich?” The whole Android ecosystem is a race to the unprofitable bottom. The same can be said about Windows PC makers - thin margins and low profits. Not exactly what I would consider a “success”. There was a period of time where you couldn't have custom keyboards on iOS. There was a period of time where 3rd party apps on iOS couldn't even multitask. And when Apple did it, it did it more securely. You can’t just press a confirmation button, the user has to be purposeful and go into settings, the keyboard runs out of process, and even then by default the keyboard doesn’t have network access. The user has to go out of their way to go back into settings to give the keyboard network access and they get a huge warning. Also, when you enter a password, it changes back to the system keyboard. As far as multitasking, again Apple was more thoughtful and limited multitasking in iOS 4 to not allow a third party app to drain the battery. Even now that they have opened it up more, the user can still granularly control what apps are allowed to run in the background. There is huge difference between the thoughtfulness of how Apple implements features and how Google implements features.