4 ms·
I'm one of those people who doesn't have to work, but I do because I enjoy it. I moved to the silicon valley nine years ago, and in that time I've done half a
by lisper 8y ago
I'm one of those people who doesn't have to work, but I do because I enjoy it. I moved to the silicon valley nine years ago, and in that time I've done half a dozen or so job interviews. I got no offers, so now I run my own company. It was different story each time, but the upshot (IMHO) is that the interview process seemed to assume that I was a fresh-out undergrad. In one case, they asked me to debug some Ruby code despite the fact that I told them well in advance that I have never worked with Ruby.
There was one notable exception, and that was my experience with Triplebyte. They have a much better technical interview process than any I have seen anywhere else. There is really only one way to assess someone's ability to write code, and that is to have them write code in a language and environment with which they are already familiar. Modern coding is so complex and requires so much infrastructure that productivity hinges as much or more on the impedance match between a person and their environment as it does on their actual abilities. Even the most brilliant coder will stumble if they use emacs day to day and you force them to use vi.
If you want to assess my ability to come up to speed on a new environment, I have a solution for that too: hire me as a contractor and give me a week or two to do a real project for you. I really don't understand why more companies don't do that.
- edoceo 8y agoYeah, gig to hire works great for my small tech company.
- greglindahl 8y agoGig to hire doesn't work if the job market is hot enough that potential employees have full-time job offers in addition to your gig-to-hire offer. I've been able to gig-to-hire for offshore developers, but never for onshore.
- edoceo 8y agoGot my most recent two employees this way, one sales, one dev, both had prior employment, I'm in Seattle
- mycall 8y agoWhat's the difference between "gig to hire" and "6 month contract" then hire if you like them?
- world32 8y agoI don't know about Silicon Valley but in the UK with contractor rates being what they are, the employee will likely make a hell of a lot more money while on that 6 month contract then they will when they get hired permanently. So it may seem to the employee like they are taking a giant pay cut in order to have a perm position.
- ghaff 8y ago>I really don't understand why more companies don't do that. In part, because it doesn't really work for most currently employed people and may even be in violation of their employment contract. Where appropriate it can be a good approach, but it probably makes more sense for people who are already consultants/contractors exploring a full-time opportunity.
- ArchTypical 8y ago> There was one notable exception, and that was my experience with Triplebyte. They have a much better technical interview process than any I have seen anywhere else This looks just like an Ad I see on reddit all over the place.
- lisper 8y agoFWIW, I'm not affiliated with Triplebyte in any way. I'm just a satisfied user.
- oculusthrift 8y agofor what it’s worth i did triplebyte as well and it was actually a really good interview process. I didn’t end up accepting an offer from any of their companies but I thought they asked very practical things instead of just algorithms.
- jefftk 8y agoFor what it's worth, lisper has been on HN for 10+ years, has 30k+ karma, and is clearly not a shill. (Disclosure: I have a friend at Triplebyte)
- dang 8y agoThis comment breaks the site guidelines, which specifically ask you not to do this. If you're worried about abuse, you're welcome to email us at hn@ycombinator.com so we can investigate. The guidelines say that too. Would you mind reading them and following them when posting here? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ArchTypical 8y agoim not going to create an email to anonymously notify the same site who will review a flagged comment anyway. So, to the process as described, no. I think the comment was timely and relevant, others just disagree about the utility.
- 8y ago
- MentallyRetired 8y agoA lot of the best programmers I know are older than me, and I'm 38. Get off my lawn.
- hazeii 8y ago> I have a solution for that too: hire me as a contractor and give me a week or two to do a real project for you. I really don't understand why more companies don't do that. Couldn't agree more; it's just not the traditional way of doing things (maybe because it doesn't scale well). It's a great way of picking a small/medium size company you like the look of, and seeing if you and the company fit together well.
- dmoy 8y ago> In one case, they asked me to debug some Ruby code despite the fact that I told them well in advance that I have never worked with Ruby. Were you applying to a place that writes a ton of Ruby?
- lisper 8y agoYes. And I told them up front, during the phone screen, that I had never written a single line of Ruby code, and they said that this was no problem, that they just wanted generally smart people, and that I could climb the Ruby learning curve after I came on board. They specifically told me that all of the coding during the live interview would be in a language of my choice. They even asked me what my preferred environment was. That particular interview was a complete disaster from beginning to end, and not just because they started out by asking me to debug Ruby code after telling me that they were perfectly OK with me not knowing Ruby. (And, just for the record, I actually succeeded in finding and fixing the bug.)
- world32 8y agoIt sounds like the problem was not your ability to debug ruby code to but your reaction to them asking you to do it. You almost sound outraged that they dared to ask you to debug some ruby code. A better candidate would have just calmly proceeded to have a go at it while explaining their thought processes to the interviewer, even if they had never coded in ruby or whatever language.
- lisper 8y ago"Outraged" is overstating it, but yes, I was pretty annoyed, but not because they asked me to debug Ruby code. I was annoyed because they lied to me. If they'd just been up front and told me they really were just looking for Ruby programmers I could have told them sorry, I am not your man, and saved everyone a lot of time.
- world32 8y ago> I was annoyed because they lied to me. That's a bit of an overstatement, chances are there was a miscommunication and the person interviewing you did not know that you had been told there would be a know ruby questions. Seriously, its just an interview, they're not going to go out of their way to accomodate your every request, just roll with it. Since you were able to debug the ruby code, its sounds like you could have gotten the job if it wasn't for your attitude. IMO the right attitude is more important than raw technical skill, you might pass the "Can he code in ruby?" part of the interview, but fail the "Can he handle things not going his way?" part. I recently had an interview for a developer job where I was asked lots of devops questions, even though it wasn't a devops-heavy role and I don't have much devops experience listed on my CV. I wasn't able to answer many of the questions but I drew on what little knowledge I did have to try and come up with answers. In the end I got the job because the interviewer said he appreciated how I tried to reason out answers to his questions even without much knowledge in the area. If I would have gotten all annoyed and started acting like I was being lied to and cheated then I doubt I would have gotten the job.
- kamaal 8y agoYou are Ron Garret, of NASA and early Google Fame. If people don't hire you, it's their loss, not yours. By the way I'm a big fan of your work, and seriously envy the quality of projects you've worked. Especially your work at NASA using Common Lisp. You sound so humble. But I'm sure a lot of people(including me) here on HN aspire to be somebody like you.
- lisper 8y agoThanks for the kind words. It's not just me, I think there are a ton of people like me out there, older, experienced, ready to contribute, but unwilling at this point in their lives to put up with a lot of bullshit. Not wanting to stomp on my humility cred here, but yes, I think the fact that the industry doesn't seem to have figured out an effective way to tap this resource is a big loss all around.
- cnasc 8y ago> There was one notable exception, and that was my experience with Triplebyte. They have a much better technical interview process than any I have seen anywhere else. I quite liked my Triplebyte interview too (all the better that I could do it with my own Emacs config and in Racket).