4 ms·
I look at this study and think "If this effect was real, it would change the world as we know it. It would definitely win the Nobel prize, and once understood
by nkurz 16y ago
I look at this study and think "If this effect was real, it would change the world as we know it. It would definitely win the Nobel prize, and once understood could almost certainly be harnessed to produce almost infinite riches."
This doesn't in and of itself affect the probability that it's a true effect, but why would you publish this study based on such a limited single trial if you truly believed you had discovered such a world changing thing? Wouldn't you at least run a second trial to confirm? Wouldn't you drop everything you were doing to try to firm it up so solidly that no rational person could doubt that you had just changed history?
This leaves me to conclude that even the original author does not believe it to be true. For if he believes he's made a discovery of this magnitude and is still standing up in front of Psych 101 courses giving the same lecture he's given for the last 20 years instead of pursuing this with every ounce of his being, he would be a fool. I do not believe he could be so large a fool, ergo, the effect is merely a statistical mirage.