4 ms·
Another nonsensical article about adtech. This is not how the industry works. Apple does not have a chance at buying Google because they have the same market c
by manigandham 8y ago
Another nonsensical article about adtech. This is not how the industry works.
Apple does not have a chance at buying Google because they have the same market cap. Google and Facebook have a massive advantage in scale and precision which is why 2 of the top 10 biggest companies on the planet are ad networks. The valuations come from the sheer profit they generate, not their assets, and how much Disney spends on content is utterly irrelevant. You cannot easily replicate what they do otherwise it would've already been done. Half of the world's population still isn't online so there's plenty of room for growth in the future too.
Everyone loves to talk about waste but skip over how much worse it is with TV and print ads. What matters is getting a positive return. Even if you can't measure anything else, you can see what sales were like before and after doing any advertising, and that's as simple as it gets. Advertising is a key component of marketing, and marketing is how a company grows and creates customers, so unless you change human behavior advertising is not going away.
- troygoode 8y agoFWIW while I don't think it would actually happen, yes, Apple could "buy" Google. When companies merge the expectation is that the resulting combined entity will equal the two companies combined market caps. Take theoretical company (Company A) worth $100MM and with a single shareholder (Shareholder A) who owns 100% of the 10MM shares of stock. They "buy" Company B which is also worth $100MM and has a single shareholder (Shareholder B) who owns 100% of Company B's 10MM shares. Company A executes this by issuing 10MM _new_ shares in Company A that will now be owned by Shareholder B. Company A now has 20MM shares and is worth $200MM because it has added Company B's assets, income, etc. Of course in practice it frequently goes terribly wrong (ref: Microsoft & Nokia, Verizon & Yahoo, many others) and I don't think Google would actually have much incentive to go along with this. Just saying it COULD be done if both companies truly believed the outcome would be favorable.
- disishhsha 8y ago> Half of the world's population still isn't online so there's plenty of room for growth in the future too. The offline half doesn’t have that much money to spend, right? Making some assumptions and approximating, would it be wrong to say that potential gains from bringing new people online ≈ global GDP growth? Currently that’s in the low single digits.
- panarky 8y agoThis is the premise of The Innovator's Dilemma. Incumbents ignore low-margin, cost-conscious customers. Innovators cater to customers the incumbents don't want and build a product that is worse than incumbent's in every area except cost. Then innovators improve the product to capture the lower tier of incumbent's customer base, then work their way up to more profitable customers. Incumbent wakes up too late, finds their customers moved to a product the incumbent always thought was worse. Lesson: don't ignore large, underserved populations or you'll find your lunch has been eaten. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma
- manigandham 8y agoLow single digits is fine when you're among the biggest companies on the planet. We're talking about 10s of billions in profit. Amazon is now getting into the space and is a strong contender to become #3 biggest player.
- village-idiot 8y agoSize is not insurance against failure. Go ask Novell.
- manigandham 8y agoNobody is claiming that it is. The point is that single-digit growth is fine when you're big because they are percentages. The 1000% growth when you're a startup does not exist when you're worth half a trillion.
- village-idiot 8y agoTrue, it just depends how fast your next competitor is growing.
- disishhsha 8y agoLow single digit growth does not justify a high PE ratio.
- darawk 8y ago> The valuations come from the sheer profit they generate, not their assets Hm? He's talking about the multiples on their earnings, aka their profit. How does anything you just said justify a high multiple?
- manigandham 8y agoThey generate profit with far less work than Disney, therefore their profit is much more protected and scalable with automation and tech. Original content and physical parks are very hard to invest in and make profitable, and Disney has had plenty of missteps recently. Also Google has Youtube which is replacing TV for many young people and full of original content that required no investment.
- darawk 8y agoa) That doesn't follow at all. How do you get from less effort to higher moat? b) So what? You're going to value a moat at a 100% premium NPV?
- manigandham 8y agoLess work to generate more money as an industry compared to Disney, that's why they have better valuations. The moat has nothing to do with that and is formed by their scale, which is almost impossible to break at this point. This is valued highly when it defends a multi-billion profit machine that nobody else can match.
- darawk 8y ago> Less work to generate more money as an industry compared to Disney, that's why they have better valuations. That speaks to margins, not moat. Margins are already incorporated in the 'earnings' number. High margins do not factor into your multiple.
- user5994461 8y ago>>> What matters is getting a positive return. In theory yes but not in practice. Many companies run ads as strict losses, until they stop spending or die, then another company will eventually the spot. The revenue equilibrium is about where Google is paid all revenues from the customers it brought. The company gets more customer but makes neither a profit nor a loss. It's very close to that in practice. It's really brutal. Google can effectively capture all profit margin from every web business in the world. That's what is happening.
- max76 8y ago> It's really brutal. Google can effectively capture all profit margin from every web business in the world. That's what is happening. Lots of companies make a lot of money on the web. Google doesn't have a monopoly of profit.
- manigandham 8y agoThat's just business mechanics. If your customer acquisition costs are equal to your sales then you're reached breakeven and the next steps are to either reduce your costs or increase your sale price to continue growth. Nothing is static and you have to keep working on the math to optimize the business at that moment. I don't see what this has to do with Google taking your profit.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]