12 ms·
Spain will soon overtake Japan in life expectancy rankings
- mamon 8y agoWe've heard this story previously about Greece, where, it turned out to be a scam: people were not reporting deaths of their elderly relatives in order to continue receiving their monthly pension payments. Which kind of busted the myth of the great "mediterranean diet". I wonder if Spain is the same thing.
- eugeniub 8y agoBy that logic, the Japanese "myth" of longevity is also busted: https://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/15/world/asia/15japan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/15/world/asia/15japan.html
- narag 8y agoIt's not. Last week a fraud like that was in national news. But it was news precisely because it's unheard of. It seems the son has some mental problems, and had a Norman Bates setup. The diet unfortunately is being abandoned by many. We're starting to see a children obesity problem. Another factor could be the universal healthcare system. Also we still take decent care of our seniors.
- MrTonyD 8y agoI find Dr. Esselstyn's observations compelling - that the Mediterranean diet is really only a good diet because it is being compared to so many poor diets. In his analysis of many countries, it is oils in the diet which correspond to the cancers and heart disease which kill so many. Like so many other diets, I think we will look back at the Mediterranean diet and wonder how we could have been so foolish.
- franciscop 8y agoWhile other countries are adding the mediterranean diet more and more into their cultures, here around the mediterranean sea we are also improving and refining it with research! I just read from Italians the same thing that I've been hearing in Spain for few years: do not burn your food, specially oil, since it's related to cancer.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoEsselstyn might be right but he is just making a best guess. His science is terrible, one uncontrolled study of 18 patients.
- MrTonyD 8y agoBut he did that study based on the data from many other countries. You are just addressing the small scale test he tried.
- int_19h 8y agoThe nice thing about the Mediterranean diet is that it's fairly easy to stick to and still have many delicious meals, compared to many others. It's no good having some perfect diet that nobody is actually going to follow.
- gonvaled 8y agoI guess you are right, the Mediterranean diet is terrible: all people following it are dying. It still seems to be one of the best available though. I hope you are right and medicine becomes more of an exact science.
- gerdesj 8y agoAlso we still take decent care of our seniors. We do too (for a given value of decent). We are UK and you are probably JP(?) Please don't assume I know where you come from - that cough right is generally reserved for Americans.
- narag 8y agoI'm Spanish and I thought it would be clear in context. Try to read my comment as an answer to the previous one.
- dis-sys 8y ago> The diet unfortunately is being abandoned by many. with soybean sauce and MSG used in so many dishes, I am afraid to say that the diet is never a good one to start with.
- cbkeller 8y agoThat is apparently also a significant problem in Japan [1], so I'm not really sure what to think as far as which region should take the prize for longevity. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/15/world/asia/15japan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/15/world/asia/15japan.html
- fujimotos 8y agoThis kind of scam is actually a minor issue and also a pretty moronic thing to do. You're destined to be doomed once you fake your parent's death.
- pvaldes 8y agoToo few cases to made any real impact on statistics probably. The real problem is that Spain is losing population at the bottom of the plot. Less young people means more percentage of elders at a given time and this would raise the life expectancy purely as a mathematical artifact.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- narag 8y agoHow could that possibly affect longevity? In the way life expectancy is defined it doesn't seem possible.
- gbear605 8y agoI’m not sure in this case, but it could be defined as the age expected to be achieved of the people currently alive. So if the population was entirely 80 year olds, the life expectancy would be around 90.
- narag 8y agoPlease don't try to infer the definition, the point of definitions is that there is one precise meaning instead of many interpretations.
- pvaldes 8y agoAnd what would be this definition? The article does not explain how they calculated it. Their link is broken. Please don't infer that all people act the same. Some countries use gallons, other liter. What is normal for one people can be weird for other. Real facts: Spain is losing population. We have one of the lower children by women ratio in the world and the big scam nuked any stability at work for many young couples worsening the situation heavily. The health system has suffered also in the last years. Less funds for public health system means people living less, not more. They should mention this important context in an article about life expectancy. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1117826/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1117826/ https://elpais.com/elpais/2016/12/16/inenglish/1481895459_844168.html https://elpais.com/elpais/2016/12/16/inenglish/1481895459_84... If we define life expectancy as "the mean number of years of life remaining at a given age, assuming age-specific mortality rates remain at their most recently measured levels" If you have less babies, you have less babies dying in their first years. Your mortality value changes. You have also less young spanish adults doing stupid things and dying young. What about the young spaniards forced to migrate to other countries and that become citizens of other countries? Do the index count a young migrant man from equator or Morocco dying in Spain as spanish mortality? Statistics are just a model, not the real life. They lie, always. We can build a statistical model to say anything we want. Is the interpretation in the correct context what counts.
- collyw 8y agoAs a Brit living in Spain the diet seems a lot better. More olive oils and less processed crap.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoAnd smaller portions.
- collyw 8y agoI have an unproven theory that a beach culture contributes as well. People want their bodies to look decent enough to show them off.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoMaybe, but even in non-beach towns (e.g. Madrid) I've found portions to generally be smaller than in the US (or Paris).
- henryhenryhenry 8y agoOil is not a health food. More plants would make that statement accurate.
- inciampati 8y agoThe Mediterranean diet is practically based on it. It's the most significant difference in the southern Italian diet and the American one. People use what would seem to be horrifying amounts of oil to a typical American. They lead active lives into their 80s and 90s. The oil supports the consumption of more vegetables (by making them more palatable). The fact that the longest lived people in the world outside of Japan are consuming very large amounts of it (Spain, Italy, Sardinia, Greece, various Mediterranean islands) should suggest it's not a bad thing to consume. For reference, people in these countries are eating 250ml a week per person (15L a year in Greece). But this is only correlation.
- agumonkey 8y ago
- sct202 8y agoFraud wouldn't be limited to high life-expectancy countries though. It would be anywhere with some kind of elderly pensions, which most developed countries have some form of, unless there are specific countries where fraud is more common place.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- delhanty 8y ago"The USA is the IHME index’s biggest loser among high-income countries falling from 43rd in 2016 to 64th in 2040, due to an increase of just 1.1 year – from 78.7 to 78.9 years." I would have made that the headline.
- krrrh 8y agoIt’s usually not good form to put a typo in the headline. They must mean an increase from 77.8 to 78.9. And still the journalist can tell that this is all highly scientific and worth reporting on because of the decimal precision. A better article would also look at the predictions made by similar bodies 22 years ago and how well they have held up.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gonvaled 8y agoNot everything is about the USA ...
- sys_64738 8y agoLooks like a mixture of the top wine consuming countries and Japan longevity.
- cultus 8y agoIt's probably moreso the Mediterranean diet and the Mediterranean climate (encouraging more walking). The evidence that wine or any alcohol consumption positively affects health is equivocal at best (I say as I drink an IPA).
- gamma-male 8y agoThere's definitely way more walking since there is no "car culture" like in the US. I've heard that olive oil plays a big role as well.
- fyfy18 8y agoOutside of the big (with good public transport) or old (where you can walk everywhere) cities, you very much need a car to get around in Spain. Most of the residential developments in the last half century has been what are called 'urbanisations', basically groups of apartment blocks in areas far from the city centre. If you are lucky there may be a small grocery store or coffee shop within the development, but for anything else you will need to travel further afield.
- kilburn 8y ago> Most of the residential developments in the last half century has been what are called 'urbanisations' Any data to back this up? I've checked eurostats [1] and the numbers don't support this assertion: 66% of all dwellings are flats (there are no flats in spanish urbanisations), and only 12% are detached houses (the most common building type in urbanisations). Also, notice that these numbers are the larger (for % of people living in flats) and smaller (for % of detached houses) in all of Europe! [1] http://appsso.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/nui/show.do?query=BOOKMARK_DS-057122_QID_478B2888_UID_-3F171EB0&layout=BUILDING,L,X,0;GEO,L,Y,0;TIME,C,Z,0;DEG_URB,L,Z,1;INCGRP,L,Z,2;INDICATORS,C,Z,3;&zSelection=DS-057122INDICATORS,OBS_FLAG;DS-057122TIME,2017;DS-057122INCGRP,TOTAL;DS-057122DEG_URB,TOTAL;&rankName1=INDICATORS_1_2_-1_2&rankName2=DEG-URB_1_2_-1_2&rankName3=TIME_1_0_1_0&rankName4=INCGRP_1_2_1_0&rankName5=BUILDING_1_2_0_0&rankName6=GEO_1_2_0_1&rStp=&cStp=&rDCh=&cDCh=&rDM=true&cDM=true&footnes=false&empty=false&wai=false&time_mode=NONE&time_most_recent=false&lang=EN&cfo=%23%23%23%2C%23%23%23.%23%23%23 http://appsso.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/nui/show.do?query=BOOKMA...
- gamma-male 8y agoSo olive oil?
- pbalau 8y agoSiestas?
- narag 8y agoExcept in summer holidays, nobody does that.
- paradoxparalax 8y agoI have spent 4 years in Andalucia, and a lot of people slept the siesta in Winter, on the higher parts, some of it were mountains' areas, at Jaen, Sevilla and Granada, on plain January, where it was pretty cold. ok it was working in the olive's fields time, so there was a fixed time for doing things system on place. Woman would stop picking olives and go to sleep. But many old spanish man slept the siesta too. Younger spanish man and foreign labor like me would go on the fields until the end of the working day.
- narag 8y agoLOL, I omitted the other situation, the one you describe of farms workers in rural areas, thinking nobody here would care and look what happened.
- pbalau 8y agoProbably I should have been more explicit, I find the concept of siestas so damn nice. I've spent about 6 months functioning like that and that was the happiest part of my life so far. Start day at 6am, do some work, get a rest at noon, be productive for the rest of the day and still have time for my social life
- whack 8y agoI see lots of exotic hypothesis being tossed around, but none of them fit Singapore, which is only slightly behind Spain/Japan. The Singaporean lifestyle is one of the most stressful, competitive and insecure in the world. The cuisine isn't particularly healthy... any more so than the cuisine you would find at most Chinese/Thai/Fast-Food places. My armchair hypothesis is that the quality and availability of medical care trumps most other factors. Singapore is known to have a great medical system, even for those not well off. This is probably also the reason USA is doing so badly. If you're in the bottom quintile, the quality and availability of medical care is awful. If we ever instituted medicare-for-all, I expect average lifespan would shoot up by a couple years at least.
- ekianjo 8y agoNo, I dont think the medical care is that much of a big factor. I think what matters for countries involved is "family care". I.e. how much are your siblings/relatives/kids going to take care of you as you get old. Compare this with the survival of people who are left alone in nursing homes, they lose many years of their potential lives. Medical care will only take care of your biology, but that's only half of the battle.
- tonmoy 8y agoWhy don’t you think medical care is a big factor? Do you have any logical reason or data to back that claim up? If what you think is right and family care is more important factor, then life expectancy would have been way higher in the past (which it wasn’t). Moreover countries like Bangladesh would be high in the life expectancy chart along with Singapore.
- ekianjo 8y agoWhat I mean is that it's not the biggest differentiator among developed countries. Not talking about developing vs developed countries here. Basically what makes you an outlier in terms of longevity is not medical care.
- onetimemanytime 8y ago
- henryhenryhenry 8y agoFor those commenting it's the oil or the wine, I suggest this resource: www.nutritionfacts.org It's an excellent non-profit to get educated on evidence-based nutrition. In short, what all blue zones have in common is 80-95% whole foods plant-based diets, moving around throughout the day, and good social support systems.
- baxtr 8y agoThat’s pretty much in line with a alter Longo’s research on longevity
- franciscop 8y agoA very interesting fact is that, even with vastly different cultures, there is a trait surprisingly common in both Spanish and Japanese cultures: family. Both cultures have parents and kids stay together until the kids mid-20s, and both take care of the parents when they become older. It feels very weird when watching USA movies for most Spanish people as there's almost a business relationship between parents and kids (and don't even get me started with the military "yes sir" style). Now I don't know if it's related or not to life expectancy, but it's a very curious common bit in very different cultures otherwise. This probably also affect to many other parts of life/politics in more subtle ways (safety nets, depression, health culture/care, etc).
- takee 8y agoI beg to differ as if we were to judge purely based on this logic China and India would have probably also been at the top of the curve, which is not really true. Both of these countries greatly value family and it's quite typical for people to stay with their parents well into 30's and beyond.
- franciscop 8y agoWhat logic? I didn't say it's related to life expectancy, just that it'd a curious random fact about those two countries at the top. It might be related, or not, but I cannot say either way. In fact, it would surprise me greatly if there was a single culture trait linked to life expectancy, instead I'd expect it to be a combination of vastly different things that make us get to the top.
- isoskeles 8y agoRandom fact: Did you notice that both countries' names end in the letter N? At least, their English spelling ends in N.
- franciscop 8y agoOh cmon, while I think my statement is relevant I cannot tell whether it's (co)related or not. Those are very different topics and you are mixing them up together.
- watchdogtimer 8y agoIf a Mediterranean diet is responsible for Spain's long life expectancy, then why has it taken them this long to achieve this top ranking? Why didn't they achieve it earlier?
- edko 8y agoSpain, as a prosperous and modern democracy, is relatively young. Before that there was plenty of feudalism, wars, civil war, dictatorship, and hunger.
- Randomswiss 8y agoModern and prosperous? Tell that to Catalan people
- gnulinux 8y agoJapanese democracy is even younger than Spain or roughly the same age but Japan has been doing better than Spain.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- randomacct3847 8y agoI wish we’d measure the health of a society by instances of chronic disease rather than life expectancy alone. For me there is not a lot to celebrate if I live slightly longer in a country with marginally better healthcare but in a state where I’m full of chronic illness caused by poor lifestyle and diet
- taneq 8y agoIf we expect Spain to overtake Japan in life expectancy, then hasn't it already overtaken it, really?
- Markoff 8y agonot if you calculate it based on deaths from current year
- dtwest 8y agoThe article mentions that the US is the worst performing developed country. I find it interesting that nobody has mentioned the US's opioid problem. Kids dying of overdoses will crush life expectancy statistics. There have been frequent articles on HN documenting this problem. Eat your veggies and don't do drugs kids. Well, the bad ones at least...
- Markoff 8y agois there some chart comparing life expectancy at certain age like let's say 30 and live expectancy dying of natural cause (no car accidents, natural disasters, crime etc.)? because these take hit on average but most of the people will not be affected by it
- known 8y agoWe need to amend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs and include life expectancy
- ethiclub 8y agoIt could/should be argued that it already has a place in the Physiological level. It's still human survival, just extended (life expectancy) and improved upon (physiological QOL)
- writinghawk 8y ago"The chief explanation for Spain’s pronounced improvement is the country’s Mediterranean diet" -- this is scientific nonsense unless the country has only just adopted a Mediterranean diet.
- tim333 8y agoI was also going to point out that it seems kind of bunk. Especially the present tense "is the country’s Mediterranean diet." They are projecting changes in 2040 for goodness sake. It should more like we are guessing the Spanish will live longer in 2040 because diet. Which as you say is much the same as what they eat now.
- keiferski 8y agoConsidering that Spain spent most of the twentieth century at war of under a dictatorship, it isn’t nonsense.
- writinghawk 8y agoYes it is. The claim made is that the change in life expectancy is due to the diet. But it's well known that "you can't explain a variable with a constant". If the diet has not changed, it cannot explain a change in life expectancy. You are suggesting that the change in life expectancy is due to a period of living without wars and dictatorships. Whether this is right or not it is certainly a much more sensible explanation, but it has nothing to do with diet.
- qwerty456127 8y agoLife expectancy is nothing. Quality of life everyone has access to is what matters. I don't want to live long, I want to live well!
- scirocco 8y agoIt's better to burn out than to fade away. Neil Young - My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue)