5 ms·
My prediction is the largest market for this will be Arab armies. Unit cohesion is the biggest problem they face and they usually abandon their equipment when f
by exabrial 8y ago
My prediction is the largest market for this will be Arab armies. Unit cohesion is the biggest problem they face and they usually abandon their equipment when faced with force. [1]
* [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZk4Yu42g0I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZk4Yu42g0I
- mads 8y agoMy Father was in Africa and in the middle east in the 50'ies and 60'ies. I remember him telling about how arabs would usually take off their boots and flee the scene in combat situations. I assumed he was joking, but maybe not...
- village-idiot 8y agoFleeing from combat I get, it’d probably be my instinct too. But why take your boots off? I personally run faster in shoes.
- freedomben 8y agoWould it be out of place to assume you haven't experimented much with barefoot running? What you say is intuitive, but in my personal experience incorrect. It took about 6 months for my body to adjust, but now running barefoot is far superior (or with minimalist shoes like the VFFs)
- village-idiot 8y agoI wear VFFs daily, have for about half a decade at this point. On uneven ground in a combat zone, littered with god knows what and where a broken ankle might mean death? Boots please.
- freedomben 8y ago> I wear VFFs daily, have for about half a decade at this point. In that case, I would be out of place to assume you haven't experimented much with barefoot running :-) > On uneven ground in a combat zone, littered with god knows what and where a broken ankle might mean death? Boots please. That is a good point, tho I don't see boots making you faster , but I concede that the ankle support and steel toes would certainly be safer, and you're gonna be a lot slower with a broken ankle. So I still think barefoot you'd be faster, tho certainly less safe. If I were fleeing in battle, I might would rather gamble my safety for some speed, but it's probably highly situational. I suspect I've just wasted a lot of time analyzing a very unlikely scenario :-)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- perfmode 8y agoOne thing that video doesn’t address is why ISIS is successful, while others aren’t.
- epicureanideal 8y agoI’m guessing unit cohesion from mutual belief in an extreme fundamentalist religion, lack of fear from the same, and horrible torturous death for not doing as commanded.
- freedomben 8y agoI would agree, tho I'm not an expert in this area but have studied it in the past. It's difficult for non-radicalized people to understand the mindset of a radicalized religious person (not limited to Muslims). Their belief is truly powerful enough to overcome the innate human fears and drive for self-preservation that we all have. It's both admirable, amazing, and terrifying at the same time. The threat of extreme tortuous death at the hand your own group is also a strong motivating factor that keeps people from defecting should their faith wane or fail them. They typically witness the horror of torture first-hand, and don't want any part of that themselves.
- i_feel_great 8y agoISIS was/is not tribally-organized like the Arab regimes, and consisted mainly of volunteers, and many (most?) were foreigner.
- perfmode 8y agoISIS is an Arab regime by most definitions.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThat seems pretty clear - ISIS fighters were mainly volunteers, at the very least the vast majority had a deep, fundamentally motivating vision in the formation of a new Caliphate. For Arab nations, on the contrary, there is very little in terms of a cohesive national identity worth fighting for, especially in places like Iraq, Libya and Syria. Thus, soldiers in their armies are basically just taking a paycheck (especially since the economy is shit otherwise). In the face of horrible torture and execution by crucifixion, not hard to see why soldiers would collectively believe it's just not worth it.
- epicureanideal 8y agoAlthough the equipment will still need to be maintained in the field, which means needing lots of technically trained people unless they want to just leave thousands of these littered around for the simplest breakdown. Could be useful in magnifying the power though if a small number of well trained people, or a small ruling caste. Less vulnerable to losing power due to lack of military manpower.
- farseer 8y agoUnless machines can fight autonomously at brigade or division level, it probably won't make a difference. Iraqi generals defending Mosul in 2014, ran away from attacking ISIS terrorists despite outnumbering them 15 to 1 [1]. All it would take is a panicking Arab general to press a button and the machines would retreat. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_Mosul https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fall_of_Mosul