5 ms·
I don't think the point here is that rationality is bad. The point is that the speaker should have acknowleged that there is something to be gained from thinker
by stpasta 8y ago
I don't think the point here is that rationality is bad. The point is that the speaker should have acknowleged that there is something to be gained from thinkers who aren't old white men in the broadly-speaking European tradition.
- sayno3 8y agoAnyone who thinks in these terms: "only old, white men are taken seriously," is certainly an idiot projecting their insecurities and failures on a scapegoat that is popular and acceptable to hate on.
- krapp 8y ago>The point is that the speaker should have acknowleged that there is something to be gained from thinkers who aren't old white men in the broadly-speaking European tradition. Why is the race, age, gender or ethnicity of the thinker relevant to the credibility of their ideas?
- stpasta 8y agoI assume that a person's background contributes to their ideas in some way (cf. Whorf/Sapir), hopefully not to their credibility. I'll let someone else come up something here. I am most interested in the fact that he said that his theory could not be improved by drawing on thinkers from other cultures. Why? Because his theory itself implies that other cultures have things to contribute. As he said, cultures have more intelligence (i.e. better theory creation powers) than individuals. One would guess, then, that he would say a good theory should maximize the number of cultures it draws from and the degree to which it draws from them. However his theory is at best the product of one culture or at worst (and I think this is what he implied in his question and answer response) the product of one individual.
- chobeat 8y agoBecause ideas are not pure and unbiased. Every single event in your life contributes to your biases, to the way you conduct science, to the way make statements and the content of these statements. Race, gender and class in this case are clearly connected because he embodies all the stereotypes of the white male STEMlord. It makes sense, he summarized readings from others like him to appeal to a crowd of people like him. The crowd is becoming aware of this echo-chamber/safe-space for engineer and questions his motives, because they have been fed the same ideas over and over and he doesn't challenge them but just reinforces them.
- leereeves 8y agoA photon doesn't care what race or gender you are. Neither does a computer. Mathematics developed in India or China or Africa works just as well in Europe, and vice versa. You're absolutely right: our thoughts and ideas are biased and impure. That's why it's so important to test them with science and reason.
- chobeat 8y agoMathematics and physics are fields where reason works pretty well (in most cases). Nobody would argue against that. But they are the exception, not the rule. Also for example, mathematics and physics are usually fields that rarely have direct applications and most of the time they provide tools for other fields. What if the physics and maths we have now, or the way we frame the problems these fields should solve, are biased? What if this bias is preventing the creation of useful tools for other fields? The problem is that we must acknowledge the impossibility to "think outside of the box" of reason. By doing so we open ourselves to a wider spectrum of possible discoveries and constructions, even within science and engineering. What exists might not be biased in itself, but the fact that we reached some results instead of others is dependant on cultural biases that exist outside the field itself and inside the individuals and organizations pursuing science and engineering.
- leereeves 8y agoWho's forbidding anyone to "think outside the box of reason"? It's rather the opposite here; some are trying to forbid reason to stray outside the box they believe it belongs in. The possibility that reason might explain mental processes appears to be so threatening that many people are attacking this video for daring to try. And not with any specific objection, but simply with attacks on reason itself.
- chobeat 8y agoThis video isn't trying anything new. These are ideas that we've seen already, just presented in a way that is palatable to engineers. Reason itself can understand its limits. That's a good thing, we are lucky and we got to that poitn. > It's rather the opposite here; some are trying to forbid reason to stray outside the box they believe it belongs in. Nobody is forbidding anything, as long as you don't make it dangerous. Excesses of reason led to great crimes in the last centuries but this is not the case. > The possibility that reason might explain mental processes appears to be so threatening that many people are attacking this video for daring to try. Reason can explain mental processes for sure: it's called neuroscience and it's a thriving field. But consciousness or intelligence are not only about mental processes. I mean, you can believe so but then we say your opinions are naive, because there's plenty of evidence that mechanicism is not enough to explain human experience. We are not attacking this video, we are criticizing it for making the same mistakes of so many reductionists before him. If the attacks seem vague is because probably you're missing the whole discourse going on in the last 20 years in the Philosophy of Mind and related fields. Also reason is not sacred, get over it.