3 ms·
He didn't just copy the software content of the disc. He reproduced the printing and labelling of the originals, and kept refining his product to look more simi
by DanBC 8y ago
He didn't just copy the software content of the disc. He reproduced the printing and labelling of the originals, and kept refining his product to look more similar to the original so they'd get through customs.
He wasn't always selling them for 25cents. There are documents from him where he's selling them for $20.
- hjek 8y ago> He reproduced the printing and labelling of the originals, and kept refining his product to look more similar to the original so they'd get through customs. Ok, I think that may justify using the word "counterfeit" then. > There are documents from him where he's selling them for $20. The thing is, it would have been perfectly legal for him to sell Debian CDs for $20. That would still have made the old computers usable again. It's good to make use of old computers, but I think the implied argument of having to copy Windows recovery CDs to save old computers is nonsense. The story just puzzles me. Maybe he didn't realise that you can sell free software[1]? [1]: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/selling.html
- dbuder 8y agoPeople want those CDs to get their computers working again with all their word documents .xls .ppt, if you mother took her wintel desktop to a local shop and came home with Debian kind or running on the random hardware what use would that be to her?
- betterunix2 8y agoOh, well, if he copied the labels that really makes a world of difference!
- DanBC 8y agoIt demonstrates dishonesty, which is what turns this from someone not knowing what they're doing into someone making the choice to engage in criminal behaviour. All of his protestation - "I was only selling them for cost" (a lie), and "I was trying to extend the life of computers" (linux would have done that, and the free downloads of Windows would have done that) - is the defence he tried to mount against the criminal charge. That defence was rejected by the court.