8 ms·
The Ghost in the Machine: An AI Perspective on the Soul [video]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rick22 8y agoIts better to download and watch as it stutters very frequently.
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agoprobably one of the best talks of yesterday. The speaker has no doubt read GEB so it might appeal to the HN crowd ... Speaking of Nominative Determinism, not only is his last name Bach, he covered Gödel's incompleteness theorem in the talk :-) I will need to re-watch this at least one more time because it was so full of goodies. The Q/A was as good as the talk itself. 13/10 would watch again :)
- platz 8y agoSpeaker did not offer an alternative to dualism as claimed. It was dualism. He just focused mostly on the mental part e.g. neuroscience and psychology. His model for explaining how brains organize thoughts (the 'easy' problem), does not address how the physical world allows for consciousness in the first place (the 'hard' problem c.f. David Chalmers https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2018/12/03/episode-25-david-chalmers-on-consciousness-the-hard-problem-and-living-in-a-simulation https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2018/12/03/epis... ).
- rick22 8y agoWhat is GEB ?
- DyslexicAtheist 8y agoGödel Escher Bach, see https://hn.algolia.com/?query=goedel%20escher&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=goedel%20escher&sort=byPopular...
- pantalaimon 8y agoIf you haven't seen then yet, Joscha also did talks in a similar vein in the previous years: https://media.ccc.de/v/30C3_-_5526_-_en_-_saal_2_-_201312291600_-_how_to_build_a_mind_-_joscha https://media.ccc.de/v/30C3_-_5526_-_en_-_saal_2_-_201312291... https://media.ccc.de/v/31c3_-_6573_-_en_-_saal_2_-_201412281130_-_from_computation_to_consciousness_-_joscha https://media.ccc.de/v/31c3_-_6573_-_en_-_saal_2_-_201412281... https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7483-computational_meta-psychology https://media.ccc.de/v/32c3-7483-computational_meta-psycholo... https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8369-machine_dreams https://media.ccc.de/v/33c3-8369-machine_dreams And if you understand German, he was also in the last Alternativlos Podcast where he talked about some ideas from this talk, but also some more https://alternativlos.org/42/ https://alternativlos.org/42/
- snailletters 8y agoJoscha Bach is great. He has many other talks available on his website. [0] His Twitter [1] is also a fun and interesting place, check it out. 0. http://bach.ai/videos/ http://bach.ai/videos/ 1. https://twitter.com/Plinz https://twitter.com/Plinz
- xfs 8y agoDid he mention Scott Aaronson's Ghost in the Quantum Turing Machine? That is a great take on consciousness and free will that I know of.
- DanielleMolloy 8y agoHe didn't mention it yesterday, but thanks for the pointer!
- mark_l_watson 8y agoInteresting, and he makes me want to GEB.
- buchhalter37 8y agoJoscha Bach is a perfect example of the tech community fetishizing its own ways of making sense of the world. Can the speaker acknowledge that his model of the world is the result of growing up in a rationality-loving Western tradition of thought? No. Can he even interpret a question as the start of a conversation rather than a challenge to his intelligence? No. Listening to Joscha Bach is like listening to the screams of computer scientists as they are slowly squeezed to death.
- sometime 8y agoThe worst aspect of our universe might be that it does not care about our feelings. We have evolved to gain status in terms of competence and knowledge, but most edifices of ideas eventually collapse (beyond ars gratia artis), because there is only one truth and many ways to perceive it. Computationalism renders centuries worth of philosophical, religious and perhaps even mathematical inquiry redundant. People have erected their careers upon claims that can be casually explained away by simple computational mechanisms. It's easy to see how the simplicity could be perceived as insulting. It's a tragedy, really and Bach might be a bit too insensitive about this.
- chobeat 8y agoCan you be more smug please? Also your dunning-kruger is showing. Simple answer to complex problems, outside science and engineering, are almost always wrong. The world is complex and naive answers are not sufficient, even if the subjectively make sense to you. The guy is part of the establishment you're talking about: reason dominated the humankind for a few centuries and we are just now managing to converge to something better, while still being immersed in a reason-based society that is crumbling, leaving big voids filled by any kind of ideological scum because the post-reason is not here yet. But anyway, your conspiracy of philosophers against engineers has no root in reality and it's just fear of the complexity of the world.
- sometime 8y ago> Simple answer to complex problems, outside science and engineering, are almost always wrong. True, but it seems that the universe is simple at its foundation and complex in some of the things that emerge from it. The standard model fits on a sheet of paper and it commonly makes predictions that are accurate to the ~20th decimal place. Neural networks can be expressed in fraction of that complexity and evolution is even simpler. Computations that emerge from these things are often complex beyond our comprehension, and hence it is a good heuristic to distrust simple explanations in the sciences about emergent phenomena such as psychology, sociology, economy and biology.
- oger 8y agoGod as a rootkit is a tantalizing analogy you could draw from his talk...
- bicubic 8y agoSounds like Catholicism with extra steps...
- goldenkey 8y agoThe reason why most atheists hate the term God is mostly because they don't understand the nomenclature like Godhead and the trinity. Even Bertrand Russell believed in God, in the same sense as this "rootkit of reality." We have a reality - unless you deny it is running on something, even itself, then an object with the same characteristic of what is commonly referred to as God, is a consequence.
- krapp 8y agoMost atheists don't hate the term God, nor do they hate God. It would be irrational to hate something that you don't even believe exists. >We have a reality - unless you deny it is running on something, even itself, then an object with the same characteristic of what is commonly referred to as God, is a consequence. That's a tautology: "reality exists, therefore God exists, given some arbitrary definition of God for some arbitrary definition of reality." Atheists don't believe in God - any God, or Gods (because consider that there are many from the Judeo-Christian complex to the ancient 'pagans' to the nameless spirits of shamanism and animism) because no religion has provided any credible evidence of their supernatural claims, not because concepts like Godhead and the Trinity are incomprehensible.