3 ms·
I did not literally pull that number out of my hat. That was a figure of speech Fair enough. No matter what wizardry your tools provide, it seems exceedingly
by pvg 8y ago
I did not literally pull that number out of my hat. That was a figure of speech
Fair enough.
No matter what wizardry your tools provide, it seems exceedingly unlikely
Wait no, this is wrong. Experts are telling you this is wrong. Non-experts (say, me) looking at the same stuff can easily see that it's wrong.
If you think my estimate is wrong, then tell me what you think the right answer is and why
I think I saw some tptacek comment in another branch of this thread about 'how many bushels does it take to get to space'. I think he's right that your arguments are in that exact realm of underinformed inarguability. I don't have to prove the halting problem to reasonably say that an airliner, with all its software, is a more reliable and safer form of transportation than a snowboard. Yet you bring this up as some sort of meaningful retort. The onus is not on me to show reasonableness.
- lisper 8y ago> Experts are telling you this is wrong. So, first of all, I am an expert. I am not on the level of tptacek, but I did not just fall off the turnip truck either. I have a Ph.D. in computer science plus ~30 years of industrial and research experience. I've been studying security and cryptography for ~20 years. I run a company that sells a security product (https://sc4.us/hsm https://sc4.us/hsm) for which I wrote much of the code myself. One of the reasons I'm skeptical about the security of iOS is because I know how easy it would be for me to conceal a back door in my own product, and my product has orders of magnitude less code and correspondingly fewer places for vulnerabilities to hide (which is supposed to be one of its main selling points, BTW). Second, it's simply not true that experts are telling me that the "this" you are referring to is wrong. The comment to which you are responding is the first time in this thread that I have raised the amended claim that the rate of decompilation is <100 BPS rather than ~1 BPS. You are the only one who has responded to that so far. Third, while it's true that tptacek has been telling me that I am wrong, he has been very vague about what exactly it is that I am wrong about. He has not directly challenged any of my claims, not even (if you read carefully) my conclusion. Neither he nor anyone else has actually made a made a statement of the form, "You're wrong, a reasonable estimate of decompilation rate is X", or, "You're wrong, a complete audit of iOS can be done in X work-days." All of the responses have been of the form, "You're wrong because you're an idiot," or, "You're wrong because you don't know the ins and outs of contemporary reverse-engineering techniques." But that, as I have noted before, is the courtier's-reply fallacy. Even if I am ignorant it does not follow that I am wrong. People get things right for the wrong reasons surprisingly often.
- pvg 8y agoSo, first of all, I am an expert. [...] You're wrong because you're an idiot You're right, this line of argument about expertise was generally unproductive and I shouldn't have gone down it. I apologize for starting it. It's dumb and it's dumb no matter how much of an expert you are or are not. I stand by 'unserious', though. 'image size' and 'halting problem' are two deeply unserious retorts to the points others were making in this thread.
- lisper 8y agoI would accept your apology, except that you immediately go on to commit the exact same sin using different terminology. "You are deeply unserious" is no different than "you are an idiot." Neither one tells me anything other than that you disagree with me, and that you think that it is so self-evident that I am wrong, or that I am so mentally deficient, that it is not worth your time to actually advance an argument. Seriously, how exactly did you expect me to respond to that? BTW, you can only "stand by" something that you have previously said, and AFAICT you just now introduced the word "unserious" into this exchange. That, to me, is an indication that you are not taking this very seriously.
- pvg 8y agoI said these arguments were unserious. I said this before, just scroll back. "Neither of these are serious, engaged-with-the-actual-topic sorts of arguments. " That's the bit I stand by.
- lisper 8y agoYou left out some important context: "first you claim that an iOS image is a black obelisk fathomless to man and when challenged and essentially forced to concede this is completely inaccurate you fall back on saying your position is generally right and what's more, both right and unfalsifiable because of Archangels Turing & Church. Neither of these are serious..." You're right, neither of those are serious. But neither of those are my argument. So I guess we actually agree about that.