7 ms·
Here is the BIG elephant on the road. Why road consumption is different than all other consumptions: We don't pay for road usage!!! Anything useful that is ha
by BurningFrog 8y ago
Here is the BIG elephant on the road. Why road consumption is different than all other consumptions:
We don't pay for road usage!!!
Anything useful that is handed out to consumers at the cost of $0.00 will be overused and develop a shortage.
This is so ingrained that it can be hard to think about.
Anyway, if we had to pay to access roads, depending on the traffic load, traffic could always flow at full speed, road investments could pay for themselves and a lot of things would be healthier in society.
I know this argument doesn't convince a lot of people... I think we just have to wait for some society to implement it first and the the rest of us can wonder at the miracle and slowly copy it. Perhaps the Chinese? The seem keen on innovating, for better and for worse :)
- chillacy 8y agoSome cities have special lanes you have to pay for to use during rush hour, FastPass is one system. They charge by number of wheels.
- BurningFrog 8y agoYeah, it's very slowly coming along!
- johnwalkr 8y agoNot quite as comprehensive as your example but in Japan all highways are tolled and the toll is approximately the same as high speed train fare. In cities all parking is paid too, normally even at your apartment. Driving is often more expensive and slower than transit. The end result is much higher pressure for maintaining good transit, good infrastructure for walking the last mile (it’s rare to see a long stretch of uncrossable road or missing sidewalk). There’s a lot of pressure to keep shops and restaurants within walking distance of most neighborhoods, too.
- BurningFrog 8y agoThanks! I didn't know about this. I'm very impressed by Japanese infrastructure, and this is one more piece explaining how they do it.
- zmmmmm 8y ago> Anything useful that is handed out to consumers at the cost of $0.00 will be overused and develop a shortage. Can you explain how I still seem to have enough oxygen to breathe? I get the point, but I don't like the absolutism applied in these kind of arguments. Similarly, I can go to a small country town with a 2 lane highway through it and somehow building that road did not induce congestion despite the fact that the article asserts a 1:1 correlation between congestion and building roads. Obviously these are silly arguments but it still all goes back to the point that we need to figure out how to model these things and each situation should be modeled and engineered on its own merits. Turning the argument into just an alternative form of dogma to what caused the problem originally is actually almost as bad as the original problem.
- BurningFrog 8y ago> Can you explain how I still seem to have enough oxygen to breathe? This is a fundamental question in economics, and the answer is that oxygen is (currently) not a scarce resource. This is not an inherent property of oxygen. In a Mars settlement, oxygen would probably be a costly manufactured good. Economics is sometimes called the "science of scarcity", and the basic economic problem as the gap between limited resources and theoretically limitless wants: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/scarcity.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/scarcity.asp Resources that are in bigger supply that the demand have nothing for Economists to study. As for roads, I'd note that they're only scarce some times. I wouldn't expect much or any road pricing to apply at nights or weekends even in heavily congested big city commute paths. And as for my "absolutism" and "dogma", I don't know what that specifically refers to. I think I'm just calmly explaining the state of the science in this field. Let me know if I need to clarify anything!