8 ms·
> state channels (ETH’s version of Lightning), but it is unclear whether main-chain issued ERC20 type tokens will be portable to this environment. The Raiden p
by DennisP 8y ago
> state channels (ETH’s version of Lightning), but it is unclear whether main-chain issued ERC20 type tokens will be portable to this environment.
The Raiden project is the closest thing to Lightning, was recently deployed to the main chain, and explicitly supports any ERC20 token.
The article says Plasma is dead because...Peter Todd, a Bitcoin dev, claims they had a similar idea and rejected it? Meanwhile, on Ethereum a bunch of teams are actively working on it and the Loom project has a version up and running.
The article asks why if proof of stake is so great, didn't Ethereum just start with that? Because proof of stake had widely-recognized security flaws (like "nothing-at-stake"), and it took years of research to fix them all.
The entire article is of similar quality.
- pouta 8y agoCan you share those fixes?
- phlip9 8y agoFirst, some Proof-of-Stake setup: 1. Assume we have some set of "validators" who control the global consensus process. They come to consensus on the current global state of the system. These validators are vaguely analogous to miners in Proof-of-Work consensus. 2. These validators have coins bonded as collateral in exchange for more voting power in the consensus process. One key idea necessary for Proof-of-Stake is to punish Byzantine validators, i.e., those who deviate from the consensus protocol, by destroying their bonded stake. If you misbehave, then you lose some proportion of your collateral. Thus, validators have incentive for participation (from rewards and fees) and a _disincentive_ for malicious behavior. This is in contrast to Proof-of-Work consensus, where there is no way to punish a specific miner that misbehaves--we cannot programmatically take away physical mining ASICs. Changing the Proof-of-Work function is only an absolute last resort as it unfairly punishes the other honest miners. So what constitutes misbehavior? When can we confidently punish another validator? An example is when a validator publishes signed attestations for conflicting forks--an example of equivocation. When presented with signed evidence of equivocation, the honest majority of validators can agree to punish the equivocator. This punishment system solves the original "nothing-at-stake" problem where a validator has no disincentive not to contribute to both sides of a fork. On another note, the OP seems to misunderstand the fundamental consistency vs availability (in the event of a partition) trade-off that consensus algorithms must to make. Bitcoin's Proof-of-Work is more AP with probabilistic eventual consistency. In the event of a partition, the side with less mining power will make transactions unaware of the partition. When the partition heals, all transactions on the weaker side will revert, effectively double spending all transaction recipients on that side. In contrast, many Proof-of-Stake protocols use a more traditional PBFT-style consensus process which favors consistency over availability. In the case of a partition, the weaker side will simply become unavailable (if it contains less than 1/3 of the voting power). In the event that no partition has >2/3+ of the voting power, the entire system will become unavailable. Also in contrast to PoW's eventual consistency, PBFT-style Proof-of-Stake allows for finality as soon as the validators come to consensus on the next block.
- aeternus 8y agoAs a new user in a Proof-of-Stake protocol, how do I determine which chain to follow? With PoW I can choose the 'longest' chain (chain with the most total work).
- stale2002 8y agoEasy. You'd probably pick the one with the biggest market cap. The whole point of money is that it is useful because everyone else is using it. So the one with the biggest market cap is almost certainly the one that you'd want to follow. Or you could not do that. You could instead pick a different one. There is nothing stopping you. If there are multiple networks, it would be obvious, and you can merely make up your own mind about which to follow. Interestingly enough, this also applies to POW chains. There is nothing stopping you from picking a shorter chain. But if I had to guess, I would say that almost nobody would be following the shorter one. This applies to POS coins as well. There would likely be 1 chain, that everyone is following. And this one chain would be obvious.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoThe client you download tells you, by giving you an accurate recent snapshot of the state.
- keymone 8y agoSo one has to trust distributors of the software? I mean it’s been known about PoS systems since inception, it’s just funny how it’s supporters never like to admit it.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoYes but you have to trust the distributors of the software anyway, even in PoW.
- keymone 8y ago
- bouncycastle 8y agoBesides Raiden, you can even impliment a simple state channel in about 50 lines of solidity & it shouldn't be too hard to adapt it to any token, see “Ethereum Payment Channel in 50 Lines of Code” by Matthew Di Ferrante https://link.medium.com/A4wqDWtj2S https://link.medium.com/A4wqDWtj2S
- danaos 8y ago> The entire article is of similar quality. You cherry-picked some points and rebuffed them, then proceeded to generalize and dismiss all of them. The reality is that any SQL database would be superior to every blockchain unless your motives are criminal nature. Disclosure: I sold all of my cryptos in Q1 2018, after buying my first bitcoin in the summer of 2013 and loosing a (luckily) small chunk of it in the infamous MtGox hack.
- swift532 8y ago> The reality is that any SQL database would be superior to every blockchain unless your motives are criminal nature. What if you're a person in China in the future, your social credit is crap, and the only way you can buy bread is over a government approved payment app?
- wslh 8y ago> The reality is that any SQL database would be superior to every blockchain unless your motives are criminal nature. People in Venezuela and other political or economically opressed people around the world don't agree [1]. It seems you are wrongly extrapolating the context where you live. [1] https://coin.dance/volume/localbitcoins https://coin.dance/volume/localbitcoins
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- vkou 8y agoThose people would rather be using USD.
- naniwaduni 8y agoThis is, I suppose, very similar to criminal motive, except that we find them sympathetic. A reminder that not all that is (locally, de facto) illegal is wrong. One man's terrorist &c.
- repomies6999 8y ago
- drcode 8y agoPeople like Tuur are so frustrating, because they complained about ethereum since day one (while lobbing lots of cheap shots at it) and now that it has turned into a big successful project, they are still around and say "see! I was right! It still hasn't cured world hunger!"
- brighton36 8y agoWhat is successful about ethereum? The price?
- drcode 8y agoWhat metric interests you? Number of stories in mainstream publications? Number of projects based on the tech in corporations? Amount of developer interest? Market cap? I agree that it is still in need of mainstream use cases, if that is your metric then you can justifiably argue no cryptocurrency is "successful".
- gcb0 8y agothe single promise of the project maybe? to enable transactions or way to fund distributed projects from direct sales to things as IPFS. it's at most a hacker toy platform.
- dlegal 8y agoMakerDAO is platform agnostic but currently exists on the Ethereum blockchain. MakerDAO is awesome, and would encourage you all to take a look. https://cdp.makerdao.com/ https://cdp.makerdao.com/ intro https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3YL_D66TjA&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3YL_D66TjA&feature=youtu.be
- tim333 8y agoIt's enabled a lot of transactions, several by myself. Indeed yesterday I did a couple of ERC20 token transfers which took less than a minute and cost two cents each.