4 ms·
(I work for Amazon, but not in the retail division. Opinions are mine and not of the company. I'm also an attorney, but this is not legal advice.) There is a
by otterley 8y ago
(I work for Amazon, but not in the retail division. Opinions are mine and not of the company. I'm also an attorney, but this is not legal advice.)
There is a channel in pretty much every company, large or small, for reporting copyright violations and other legal complaints. That channel is the legal department (in the US, the DMCA contact point), not the customer service department. If you want a company to actually take action, you have to get the right people involved.
In Amazon's case, it's right here: https://www.amazon.com/report/infringement https://www.amazon.com/report/infringement
If you complain to the wrong people, expect a suboptimal response. They're not trained to help in these cases, and don't always have the authority to short-circuit the bureaucratic process like the legal department does.
- Balgair 8y agoAside: Thank you for all the help here! These comments are amazingly helpful. Do you have a blog or other repository of this knowledge such that we can search for it there? Though I have no issues with Amazon now, I can imagine I may have some in the future. Searching through old HN comments to try to find this data is, well, sub-optimal. Again, thank you!
- CamelCaseName 8y agoAs the article/message chain clearly shows, the author did submit an infringement report to that link. In fact, so have I. As the author posted a screenshot of, you get an email reply after some time saying something to the effect of "We have reviewed and removed the content" ...except, nothing was removed. The infringing content is still there. The exact same thing happened to me. Same exact email. Edit, here's my email from Amazon: https://i.imgur.com/mzXycfk.jpg https://i.imgur.com/mzXycfk.jpg -- nothing was actually removed.
- otterley 8y agoI looked at the thread and it appears that the product ID (ASIN) that was the subject of the original takedown request was not the same as the ASIN of the the subsequent complaint. If it appears on multiple catalog pages, or a subsequent violation is alleged, each ASIN must be reported. Unfortunately this is the downside of being an IP rights holder - policing is a PITA. (Amazon, do their credit, does offer a brand registry, but that protects against trademark infringement, not copyright infringement.) In your case, assuming they did not do exactly what they said they would do (remove the infringing content from the specific listing page referred to by the ASIN), I'd have your attorney send a takedown notice to the following address: Copyright Agent Amazon Legal Department P.O. Box 81226 Seattle, WA 98108 If your content is on multiple product listings, you'll need to identify each ASIN.
- gabrielblack 8y agoI hope that Amazon, in case of repeated violations, will take down the sellers, giving the information to right enforcement organizations. If changing the ASIN is enough to continue, no surprise if it becomes the counterfeiter heaven. This is a serious matter, counterfeit electronics can damage things and peoples, even kill them creating fire or discharging lethal electric power.
- CamelCaseName 8y agoAh! Good catch! I didn't see that the ASINs were different, yup, you have to report each ASIN. I'll keep that address in mind for next time. Thanks!
- zepolen 8y agoSo nothing stops a copyright infringer re-uploading the content with a new ASIN? I think only a hefty fine for both the infringer and Amazon would make them think twice about doing it again.
- otterley 8y agoThe DMCA expressly gives entities that publish user-generated content a “safe harbor” exemption from such liability if they handle authorized takedown requests in a reasonable amount of time.
- tsevis 8y agoExactly! So Amazon makes money from our work. And they even makes us lose time with reporting items that simply change numbers. What a shame!
- mimi89999 8y agoDo you really want platforms to decide what can be put and what can't be? How should they decide that an article is IP infringement and what isn't?
- alok-g 8y agoI am guessing your case was also similar to this comment here [1]. Amazon must have removed as requested and responded back to you saying so, however, the seller bypassed with a new account and uploaded again. You may be able to check. PS: I haven't read the OP yet since it's behind Facebook login. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18780734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18780734
- CamelCaseName 8y agoInteresting. I wonder if they have some kind of automated system to reupload images after an infringement takedown, because I recall checking the ASIN maybe 20 minutes after I received that email and it was still there. The infringer did not seem very sophisticated at all so I'm not quite convinced, but that is certainly a possibility I had not considered. Also, I grabbed the thread from the OP in case you were interested: https://imgur.com/a/L1gFAqy https://imgur.com/a/L1gFAqy
- andrei_says_ 8y agoA company training its staff to forward copyright complaints to the appropriate channel is trivial. Expecting all customers of a company to be magically educated about the proper channel for copyright complaints is much less realistic imo. A company making profit from counterfeits making counterfeit reporting unintuitive sounds a bit suspicious.
- otterley 8y agoFirst, you’re mixing up counterfeit goods with copyright violations. They’re not identical. Different bodies of law, but it’s easy to confuse the two. At any rate, if you’re an IP rights holder, knowing how to deal with violations is table stakes for your legal representative. Googling “amazon copyright notice” gives you the correct page link near the top of the first results page.
- tsevis 8y agoI have reported the item on their correct page. By the way you can try to report it yourself right now. You cannot. You simply get the message that the ASIN or URL is wrong.
- hopler 8y agoThanks, unofficial Amazon representative, for explaining that Amazon's policy on copyright infringement is to misappropriate a little on every sale (small enough to not be worth the victims' cost of pursuing a claim) and make large profits on a high volume of offenses. Way to burnish your reputation.
- otterley 8y agoTo be clear, to my knowledge, this is not Amazon’s policy. Their policies are clearly laid out here: https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/help.html?itemID=U5SQCEKADDAQRLZ&language=en-US&ref=efph_U5SQCEKADDAQRLZ_relt_201361070 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/help.html?...
- thatoneuser 8y ago
- thatoneuser 8y agoSo you’re telling the people reporting things it’s /their/ fault that this activity is thriving? Amazon bears no responsibility for taking a complaint like this in /any/ channel and making an appropriate response? Come on. This isn’t a mom and pop store. This isn’t a company that can’t figure out logistics. This is amazon. If they don’t forward these complaints to the right place of their own volition, then they aren’t working hard enough to abide by the law. Fair is fair. Corporations need some responsibility to go with all their privileges.
- hopler 8y agoYou're not wrong, but Amazon isn't going to do the government's job for it. If they can get away with stealing, they will.
- pergadad 8y agoBreaking safe harbor rules, stuffing & adding counterfeits,... The only issue is outings that it's too costly to sue them and they'll find a way to weasel their way out of it.
- Spivak 8y agoI don't really see how Amazon is breaking safe harbor rules. The case law surrounding OCILLA makes it very clear the service providers have no obligation to seek out copyrighted content on their site and instead rely near exclusively on reports from copyright holders.
- tsevis 8y agoI am the artist who's work is sold illegally on Amazon. There is no excuse for Amazon. Absolutely none. 0! I have reported the URL. It never changed. I don't know when the ASIN changed but the URL remained the same. The new ASIN or URL cannot be reported. I am getting the message that the ASIN is wrong whenever I am trying to report it. I am getting silly answers from silly people who are bullshiting me. They have a seller who is selling fake products. What a serious company does is to close his store. Especially when they learn that an item that is take off is up again. After days of complains I decided to complain on Facebook. They are bullshiting me there as well. It's a real shame!
- otterley 8y agoThe ASIN is embedded in the listing page URL, so if the ASIN changed, so did the URL. Out of curiosity, what’s the current URL? If you’re tired of chasing an infringer, why don’t you hire an attorney to engage Amazon’s legal department? You might end up with a more satisfactory result than by constantly playing “whack-a-mole” with reporting individual listings. You can also separately report a seller by following the instructions here: https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/help.html?itemID=U5SQCEKADDAQRLZ&language=en-US&ref=efph_U5SQCEKADDAQRLZ_relt_201361070 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/help.html?...
- tsevis 8y agoI will see what I will do. However the problem is much bigger. Amazon should take down a shop when they know that the seller is simply changing the ASIN. But this isn't the only problem. I tried to report 10 different items. It was possible to report just 3. Their system isn'r recognising the other 7 ASINs. So Amazon really has a system that makes difficult to impossible to find your right. Hiring an attorney costs money. They know it and this is why they are making it as the only option.