4 ms·
Most of those pedestrian tunnels are pretty unpleasant; everyone I know regards them as a necessary evil at best. Tunnels are inherently not human-friendly spac
by lmm 8y ago
Most of those pedestrian tunnels are pretty unpleasant; everyone I know regards them as a necessary evil at best. Tunnels are inherently not human-friendly spaces (limited natural light) so I don't think you'll find any real success stories for pedestrian tunnels; better to put the cars in tunnels if you must go that route.
- freeone3000 8y agoMontreal's underground is a pretty strong counterexample. The pedestrian "tunnels" have retail, dining, etc on the sides, with strong artificial lighting and skylights when possible. It's closer to a mall than a tunnel, and they're quite nice.
- kingo55 8y agoThis is the same for Korean cities - you physically can't cross roads of busy intersections... and like in Montreal, there are plenty of shops and amenities underground. Carrot AND stick.
- eigenvector 8y agoToronto also has a quite extensive and successful underground mall - the 'Path' - but I'd imagine it's success is in part due to the climate. Walking underground is vastly preferable to above ground for a good portion of the year. It also allows access from Financial District office towers to Union Station unimpeded by traffic lights.
- ajmurmann 8y agoThere is of course also the option of a bridge/elevated walkway system that seems to be working really well in Hong Kong. At least I loved it.
- lmm 8y agoThat was tried in London and went badly. Pedestrians don't like having to go up and down a lot, and there's a bootstrapping problem with trying to create a nice environment at high level. Better to keep street level for the pedestrians.
- kthejoker2 8y agoHouston's downtown tunnels are thriving and kind of an awesome hidden secret.