2 ms·
There are plenty of examples going in both directions, it's not a matter of absolutes, or can be resolved in some political us vs them style argument (all liber
by dmix 8y ago
There are plenty of examples going in both directions, it's not a matter of absolutes, or can be resolved in some political us vs them style argument (all libertarians are idiots, all gov is great, etc).
NASA's greatest successful decade happened shortly after they swept up all of the private organizations and talent from universities to form the organization. It's been said their efficient culture at the time reflected private industry culture that remained, combined with the rigour and scale of the job at hand found in university and government experience they had access to.
Everyone loves pointing to NASA 1950/60s accomplishments as the counter-point to private industry but basically just because gov finances something doesn't mean the positive effects of private industry can't still linger in government agencies well after they've been founded. Where the negative effects of top-heavy administrative machines, with endless risk-management and management-staff itself taking precedent over engineering talent (https://www.jerrypournelle.com/reports/jerryp/iron.html https://www.jerrypournelle.com/reports/jerryp/iron.html) have not yet crippled their R&D efforts.
That said, no one said gov isn't capable of great things but whether it's a sustainable repeatable thing as long-term large-scale organizations acting in a waterfall-esque process - I'm not so sure. The ideal is probably some middle ground where gov organizations can take an entrepreneurial style approach building small teams, while still providing them the access of gov resources and public-incentive structure, but without the damaging effects of administrative culture.
I'm not convinced gov contractors are the solution to this either due to the aforementioned public incentive structure and how it encourages graft, crony-capitalism, and poor oversight of public spending.
Not to mention context is incredibly important Fusion and the first humans in space are at a different scale than "first person to fly", given the amount of resources the Wright Brothers required. So again it's not black/white.
- ufmace 8y agoThere are indeed many examples of both Government and private industry succeeding and failing. Perhaps the differentiator is bureaucratic interference, which private industry is somewhat less prone to, but by no means immune from. Government, meanwhile, tends to create over-bureaucratized organizations, but can sometimes under some conditions create highly efficient organizations in some places. Perhaps it's a good thing that we still have plenty of diversity in organization so that we can try all possible options for how to do something. New, small, and inexperienced companies, large and highly organized companies, and government departments large and small can all try their hand at creating new things.