3 ms·

Maybe it's the time for us to get a RNLI?

by pbalau 8y ago

gerdesj 8y ago
You might want to drop the R bit but actually the same org works across both the UKoGBnNI and the Republic of Ireland in a rare example of pragmatism. The US Coast Guard has a rather different remit to the RNLI which is devoted purely to rescue. I believe the USCG has other duties as well. Contrast: https://www.uscg.mil/ https://www.uscg.mil/ and https://rnli.org/ https://rnli.org/ The UK and Eire have a huge coastline relative to their land area and the RNLI are a treasured institution. Mostly staffed by volunteers and financed as a charity. We also have a Coast Guard which is actually responsible for search and rescue at sea. It's a little bit complicated but you will be pulled out of the water by a very highly trained civilian volunteer. There is no reason not to start a non military ANLI. The RNLI already have boat designs that are proven and a operational model that is also proven. Just copy it.
- ryacko 8y ago
  There was one. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Life-Saving_Service https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Life-Saving_Se...
  - gerdesj 8y ago
    Then this happened: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coast_Guard_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coast_Guard_Act You (US) have made your choice on how you want to be rescued at sea and we have made ours. They are simply different models on how to do it.
    - dingaling 8y ago
      The UK didn't really make a deliberate 'choice'. The RNLI evolved to fill a need that Government wasn't funding; the Coast Guard is only two years older than the RNLI but was formed to prevent smuggling and to protect shipwrecks. Once the RNLI was founded as a charity there was of course no pragmatic reason to dedicate tax money to that mission, so here we are today. The contracted Coast Guard helicopter pilots on £150k each hovering beside a lifeboat staffed by volunteers. Whilst the paid RNLI executives sleep. Something's not right there and that's not a model I'd encourage others to adopt. If maritime rescue is considered worthwhile then it should be professionally rewarded, and at all levels.

Maybe it's the time for us to get a RNLI?

by pbalau 8y ago

Maybe it's the time for us to get a RNLI?

You might want to drop the R bit but actually the same org works across both the UKoGBnNI and the Republic of Ireland in a rare example of pragmatism. The US Coast Guard has a rather different remit to the RNLI which is devoted purely to rescue. I believe the USCG has other duties as well. Contrast: https://www.uscg.mil/ https://www.uscg.mil/ and https://rnli.org/ https://rnli.org/ The UK and Eire have a huge coastline relative to their land area and the RNLI are a treasured institution. Mostly staffed by volunteers and financed as a charity. We also have a Coast Guard which is actually responsible for search and rescue at sea. It's a little bit complicated but you will be pulled out of the water by a very highly trained civilian volunteer. There is no reason not to start a non military ANLI. The RNLI already have boat designs that are proven and a operational model that is also proven. Just copy it.

ryacko 8y ago
There was one. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Life-Saving_Service https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Life-Saving_Se...
- gerdesj 8y ago
  Then this happened: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coast_Guard_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coast_Guard_Act You (US) have made your choice on how you want to be rescued at sea and we have made ours. They are simply different models on how to do it.
  - dingaling 8y ago
    The UK didn't really make a deliberate 'choice'. The RNLI evolved to fill a need that Government wasn't funding; the Coast Guard is only two years older than the RNLI but was formed to prevent smuggling and to protect shipwrecks. Once the RNLI was founded as a charity there was of course no pragmatic reason to dedicate tax money to that mission, so here we are today. The contracted Coast Guard helicopter pilots on £150k each hovering beside a lifeboat staffed by volunteers. Whilst the paid RNLI executives sleep. Something's not right there and that's not a model I'd encourage others to adopt. If maritime rescue is considered worthwhile then it should be professionally rewarded, and at all levels.