3 ms·
But then you no longer get back 10-1 elements, you get back 10-1+1.
by StavrosK 8y ago
But then you no longer get back 10-1 elements, you get back 10-1+1.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoSo what? You're going to have off-by-one errors no matter what convention you adopt. Python glosses over it by providing the alternative syntax x[-1] for what you would otherwise have to write as x[len(x)-1]. But it's at least as valid to provide alternative syntax for inclusive ranges. And logically, if the first element of x is x[0], the last element should be x[-0], not x[-1]. Half-open intervals are appropriate when you're thinking of them as subspaces of a continuum. When you're thinking of them as subsequences of discrete elements, closed intervals are usually more natural. Ruby is the only language I know that really seems to have tried to address the problem, providing different syntax for every way you might want to take a subsequence from an array: x[5..8] # elements [5] through [8], including [8] x[5...9] # elements [5] through [9], excluding [9] x[5, 4] # four elements, starting at [5] If you were working in pure, pencil-and-paper mathematics, you'd choose whether to index a particular sequence from 0 or 1 based on what made your formula look nicer. Both are common. But that's not an approach I'd suggest for a programming language.
- int_19h 8y agoOne thing I would add - using negative indices to index from end is a bad idea in general, because you may inadvertently end up with a negative index as a result of a calculation that you expected to always be positive - and then instead of an out-of-bounds error, you get silent wrong behavior. IMO, it's better to have dedicated syntax for index-from-end, as part of the range syntax. Again, Nim does that: x[0..^1] (although unfortunately they didn't make it symmetric).
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> IMO, it's better to have dedicated syntax for index-from-end, as part of the range syntax. This is true, and note that my suggestion requires it -- the only way to distinguish x[-0] from x[0] is to have the parser do it; -0 and 0 are the same number.
- int_19h 8y agoI mean, you could technically distinguish between positive and negative zero, if your numbers are all floating points (like JS or Lua). But that would be even more of a horror show.