5 ms·
This is exceptionally callous way of looking at things. Video games are certainly a medium for discussion: "Papers Please" is a discussion point on legal immigr
by dragontamer 8y ago
This is exceptionally callous way of looking at things. Video games are certainly a medium for discussion: "Papers Please" is a discussion point on legal immigration for example. (Its not true across the board: "Prison Architect", is NOT a discussion point on prisons).
I'm not one to play "political" games, but IMO, they are no different than political or personal movies, poems, or letters. Video games are just one more medium of which society can use to connect and communicate with other people.
Have you played the "This is fine" flash game? Its actually a deeply personal + political discussion point as well.
https://namsang.itch.io/thisisfine https://namsang.itch.io/thisisfine
These games aren't necessarily designed for maximum enjoyment, they're optimized for maximum discussion and community connections.
- reificator 8y ago> (Its not true across the board: "Prison Architect", is NOT a discussion point on prisons). I mean... to a degree it is. Certainly not to the same degree as Papers Please, but that's a high bar. Or maybe I just read my own assumptions into the game...
- kiriakasis 8y agoIt is a discussion just by its setting. Into it you can read clues on how the author or the community perceive some stuff. But it is not meant in any specific way to communicate a point, or to be a critique or prisons, or even to just make you think. It does not make you feel bad when you slaughter inmates, it does not try to portray them as people; not even as dehumanized people, this kind of analysis is just not in the game. (Disclaimer: I played it a while back, maybe it changed from the last time I saw it)
- reificator 8y ago> it does not try to portray them as people; not even as dehumanized people It was an explicit goal of theirs to do that, including giving every prisoner a backstory. Whether they accomplished their goal of portraying them as people is a different story, but they did try.
- developer2 8y agoThe argument is that the article has nothing to do with gaming. The author just happens to be a game developer, and so this is their outlet to deal with their grief and/or guilt. The text itself talks about games, but that's not really the topic being discussed; they're just advocating for others to pay attention to their cause. ^ Also an exceptionally callous way of looking at things.