3 ms·
I'm surprised cell towers can't tell connected phones what the local emergency number is, and then dial that instead when 911 isn't working correctly.
by jrockway 8y ago
I'm surprised cell towers can't tell connected phones what the local emergency number is, and then dial that instead when 911 isn't working correctly.
- ThePadawan 8y agoThat sounds like a MITM attack waiting to happen.
- jkepler 8y agoIsn't that exactly what cops or others do when they use a Stingray phone tracker and intercept people's mobile phone connections? I still remember in late 2013/early 2014 when I lived in Kyiv, Ukraine, and my friends at the Maidan protest against the government said everybody within geographic proximity of the protest received SMS messages from an unlisted number telling them their protest wasn't 'legal'. Everybody assumed it was the Ukrainian government security forces using a Stingray or similar device as a MITM between their devices and the network.
- Crosseye_Jack 8y agoIf the government is in control of the network or can can order / request the network to do so it would be fairly trivial to send a message to anyone connected to a cell tower. The thing is if the tower is serving a lot of people you could end up sending the message to people not involved so you could use a IMSI catcher (you can even make them out of a TV Tuner turned SDR receiver[0]) to catch IMSI's in a smaller area or use triangulation to narrow down the pool of devices in an area and then use that list to send SMS from the network itself. The UK did trails of using location based text messages back in 2013 in order to be used for Public emergency alerts [1] When you can gain access to the network their is no real need to MITM it, but yeah I believe a sting ray type device could also do the same as they act as a tower and trick your phone into connecting to it. [0] https://github.com/Oros42/IMSI-catcher https://github.com/Oros42/IMSI-catcher [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/mobile-alerting-trials-for-public-emergencies https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/mobile-alerting-t... (link to the info about the trial and the final report)
- bdamm 8y agoCell towers likely don’t run the actual cellular service; they’re just rf points that run the phone applications on top. And if a provider has a fleet of super duper towers that could do it, there’s a certain operations job to be done that needs to be perfectly done. Not trivial. Doable, perhaps, but that would have to be a well rehearsed job for any hope of consistent fleet wide success.
- g_p 8y agoCell networks (but not towers) effectively do this already - when you dial 911 (or 112), the phone doesn't actually dial the number "911" or "112"; instead it requests a call of type emergency. This is routed by the mobile network itself, according to how it handles emergency calling. The phone also enters a specific "access class" (access class 10) for emergency calling mode, which lets it join other masts on networks it wouldn't normally operate on. (This is where the message "emergency calls only" originates from) But if the onward system this "un-numbered" emergency call would be passed onto is unavailable (as it sounds like is the case here) then emergency calls will fail. It might be possible to dynamically reconfigure the mobile network core , but you'd need to configure this on the core, for each and every cell tower or group of cell towers, to route the call to the right alternative lines/number. Whether that system has capacity to handle all these calls is another question.
- jsjohnst 8y ago> for each and every cell tower or group of cell towers, to route the call to the right alternative lines/number Cell towers have virtually nothing to do with routing calls. That’s all centralized in a region with all the towers back hauling.