3 ms·
Philosophical take: From humanity's very biased point of view, if we assume we are smart and conscious -- and that is a severely questionable assumption! -- I
by pdimitar 8y ago
Philosophical take:
From humanity's very biased point of view, if we assume we are smart and conscious -- and that is a severely questionable assumption! -- I view progress / entropy as two kinds:
(1) "Natural", non-directed movement of a system from one stable state to another. The chaos theory outlines these processes fairly well: basically longer periods of semi-stable system which is always on the brink of the chaos but almost never tips over to it, and then sudden cataclysmic changes which are quickly followed by new semi-stable states. This is related to external factors that upset the balance.
(2) "Non-natural", or movements of a system directed by external agents. This is a conscious effort to break the currently existing balance. This implies understanding of the system and its dynamics, it implies dissatisfaction with that current state, and finally it implies understanding how to modify the system in a way that is deemed favorable to the interfering agents.
Since we are not that smart as we think, #2 is almost always inevitably leading to cataclysmic changes because we don't have good enough understanding of the entirety of the system we are trying to modify in our favor. Combine that with the fact that we are always arrogantly thinking that we can grasp everything at once -- or simply don't care and never consider the bigger picture in the first place -- and cataclysmic changes are basically inevitable. They just happen on a longer time scales than we are used to think about.
So "progress" in the way we perceive it today -- related to our so-called "civilization" -- is definitely non-natural. But we are definitely working towards our own end... or at least towards our next evolutionary stage.
I believe that we are already outside of the cycle of natural entropic changes in our own ecosystem and societal systems.
- glamblor 8y agoTo paraphrase: "Unguided arms races (blindly fumbled through) are bad, because they lead to ground shaking events, not unlike the Cambrian explosion, very obviously followed by the Cambrian extinction event." [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian_explosion [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian-Ordovician_extinction_event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian-Ordovician_extinction... Massive competition leads to a decisive, if catastophic, yet Pyrrhic victory of attrition, perhaps? Also, I think with: "very biased" to describe point of view is an unnecessary editorialization, , and "severely questionable assumption" I totally disagree with.
- pdimitar 8y ago> Also, I think with: "very biased" to describe point of view is an unnecessary editorialization, , and "severely questionable assumption" I totally disagree with. Well, I am questioning our own assumption that we are intelligent and conscious. All we know is our current level, and some of us can imagine a possible higher level. But that might not even describe a "true" intelligence and consciousness. Because if anything, so far agent Smith from the first "Matrix" movie is right: we act more like a virus and not like mammals. You can disagree with my wording of course, but do you disagree with the premise? > Massive competition leads to a decisive, if catastophic, yet Pyrrhic victory of attrition, perhaps? Yes, this is how it looks like. If there's gonna be some sort of big war where everybody gets to pull out their biggest sticks then it definitely won't at all matter who is gonna win because by the time the "victory" arrives the Earth is probably gonna be an uninhabitable wasteland. Our military are like that. There might not be anything remaining to fight for but their values will likely compel them to fight until the bitter victory. And it's very likely it will be bitter indeed.