3 ms·
Such a website would be really interesting and would probably rise some interesting questions and answers and may well be a good idea. However, being a fierce c
by roenxi 8y ago
Such a website would be really interesting and would probably rise some interesting questions and answers and may well be a good idea. However, being a fierce capitalist, I want to draw out the problems this line of thinking has if it is carried to its logical conclusions.
1) At some point people will stop buying coffee due to its price. Where is that point and how do we find it if it is not the one determined by the cafes and customers as is currently the case? If we can double wages and prices are still 'reasonable', why can't we double them again and again? When do we know we've hit 'reasonable'? Who controls what that word means?
2) You've divided a large number (double wages) by a large number (drinks/hr) and come up with a small number. The maths is fine, but the maths is obscuring the fact that the changes are large. I dunno what you are being charged for a coffee, but $0.31 is ~3% of $10 and that is quite large. Anyone who is on a disciplined budget would buy less coffee if coffee is coming out of their discretionary spending.
The argument here might be that coffee is a tiny percent of someone's expenses, but the issue is that the 'only $0.31' thinking doesn't scale. If a bunch of things rise in price by 3% in real terms, consumers with no savings (ie, most consumers) DO have to cut back on something with mathematical certainty.
- rossdavidh 8y agoYes, and whatever it is that they cut back on, it is probably no more worthy than more wages going to people in the bottom portion of the income distribution.
- epicureanideal 8y agoBut the wages not being spent by others (because they're paid to the barista) would then be spent by the barista, which then means other businesses could raise their prices a bit... The barista making $10 more per hour can go out and buy dozens of coffees of their own, or meals out at restaurants, or movies... It would keep the lower level of the economy moving.
- roenxi 8y agoHow can money get to the barista if it is "not being spent by others"? All the barista's income is coming from wages spent by consumers on coffee. The point is, gp said "it isn't unreasonable" with the implication that nobody would notice (eg, "enough to cause people to massively switch to instant coffee"). That isn't a safe position - it is likely consumers of coffee will have to cut back on something. They would notice. On your specific point that you think allocating more resources to baristas will help the economy - why not allocate the baristas to doing something more useful, where the market rate for their time is higher than $10? Allocating more to baristas is a lot of things, but it is not an evidence based strategy for increasing the general prosperity. What is it that these baristas lack? Maybe they should be trained to produce that thing, instead of getting handouts or fighting with their employers?