5 ms·
The average mainland Chinese person who attended their public school system will simply not be aware of a great many historical events, such as: The Stasi Rom
by walrus01 8y ago
The average mainland Chinese person who attended their public school system will simply not be aware of a great many historical events, such as:
The Stasi
Romanians lynching Ceaușescu
Tiennamen Square (they'll know it exists as an innocent landmark in the capital, not the history of what happened there)
1984 and the whole genre of dystopian police-state literature
- yourbandsucks 8y agoIt's to be expected that they'll know less about european history and correspondingly more about chinese history. And everyone knows what happened in Tiananmen square. It's living memory. We could flip it around and talk about how ignorant westerners are of Chinese history..
- pnw_hazor 8y ago...flip it around and talk about how ignorant westerners are of their own history. However, researching, blogging, or talking about such lesser known dark/embarrassing events will not get you or your family barred from travel, public schools, and such.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoWell, that's a matter of opinion. How many stories about deplatforming have we had lately? "But those people are legitimately awful!" you say, and I agree with you, yet.. maybe other cultures have other norms? Maybe we should learn a little Chinese history before we presume to dicatate what their norms should be. The linked video is pretty good for imparting context on this issue, I'd recommend watching it.
- ep103 8y agoYeah, I mean, that I expected. What I wasn't expecting, and still cannot wrap my head around, is how thoroughly ingrained the cultural avoidance is to learning about anything in that intellectual space. I would have expected that upon hearing about such a program, both the thoughts "This might be good" and "This might be bad" would occur to a person, and both be potentially investigated, even if only quietly and internally. But instead, it seems as if any intellectual space that could be considered even slightly controversial is often avoided by reflex, far before you get the chance to have the "this might be good or this might be bad" thought. I was going to give an anonymized example of the above, but out of respect for the person have chosen not to do so in such a public forum.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAs long as China keeps growing and people's standard of living increases I don't think people will care. The system will face its true test once they have a major economic crisis and people will have doubts about the system. Until then most people will happily go along.
- Sol- 8y agoThe average mainland Chinese person may also have legitimately nothing to fear from a social credit system. I'm not defending it, but as long as the system does not escalate (which is probably not a given, despite all the slippery slope arguments), the average apolitical person might not even have to care. I guess the combination of social credit system and censorship makes things particularly insidious, because if you are unjustly affected then you can't appeal publicly. But at the same time, enough people will get good social credit scores that a majority of the population might support the system still.
- devy 8y ago> The average mainland Chinese person who attended their public school system will simply not be aware of a great many historical events, such as: > Tiennamen Square (they'll know it exists as an innocent landmark in the capital, not the history of what happened there) False. I was born in China in the early 80s and I witnessed the 1989 riots during Tiananmen Square on TV (I was in kindergarten). Average mainland Chinese people knows more than you think they do. Albeit, a lot of them would have very different idea of the same historical events.
- theseadroid 8y agoChinese here. I dont wanna argue about other misinformation this thread have presented so far but just one thing: Access to the book 1984. jd.com is like amazon equivalent in mainland China (amazon.cn has less traffic there) Searching 1984 returns: http://search.jd.com/Search?keyword=1984&enc=utf-8&wq=1984&pvid=4619e0e60c4d4f8bbc611b9028f834de http://search.jd.com/Search?keyword=1984&enc=utf-8&wq=1984&p... the first item has 93k reviews. On taobao (by alibaba) the search results are: https://www.taobao.com/list/product/1984%E5%A5%A5%E5%A8%81%E5%B0%94.htm https://www.taobao.com/list/product/1984%E5%A5%A5%E5%A8%81%E... I dont know where you get the idea that average mainland Chinese person who attended their public school system (we dont really have a private school system yet, for better or worse) are not aware of those things.
- gpm 8y agoSmall language note, "public school" is an ambiguous term when used internationally like this. For whatever reason in the US, Canada (and probably some other countries) "public school" means "free government run school". Meanwhile in the UK (and wikipedia tells me India and Australia) "public school" means "non government school you have to pay to go to". I'm guessing that you mean the American version of "public school"?
- theseadroid 8y agoHey yes. Most Chinese schools and universities are government run and funded majorly by the government. There are a small number of private funded schools (especially English only international schools which are really really expensive) and not many people attend those.
- wholien 8y agoAs someone who went to Chinese schools, the hierarchy (at least in my city) was: Kindergarten, Elementary, and Middle school: private schools were better, or perceived as better. People actively vet their schools if they can, my parents went to 3-4 schools before deciding to send me to one. There used to be a test to get into Middle schools (7-9th grade), but they abolished it, so now parents try to "donate" their way in if they can or somehow pass the interview process. Some public schools were good, but some perception was you could not control for quality, so if you can pay a tuition then you should find a school and pay it. For high schools (10-12th grade), the public schools reigned king. This is (I think) because you have to take a test to get into. Some private schools are good, but the very very best (multiple kids get into Peiking/TsingHua/Ivy League etc) highs schools are all public and purely meritocratic in terms of getting in. There are international schools, but those are only open to foreign nationals.